# Israel/Iran Dynamics, Political Islamist Power Agenda (Episode 5) Published: 2025-07-19T03:28:50+00:00 ## Summary Veteran blogger and author Syed Akbar Ali joins the podcast to dissect Middle Eastern geopolitics, the realities behind Iran and its proxies, and how political elites instrumentalize Islam for domestic power consolidation. He argues that long-term societal progress across the Muslim world requires shifting governance away from unyielding religious dogma toward rational, scientific truth and pragmatic diplomacy like the Abrahamic Accords. ## Key Takeaways - [5:29] Societal and educational policy decisions take decades to manifest, with Malaysia currently suffering the accumulated negative consequences of historical missteps. - [17:14] Iran and Israel do not represent mutual existential invasion threats given geographical distance, rendering Iranian bellicose rhetoric primarily domestic propaganda. - [27:14] Iranian-backed proxy militias like Hezbollah and Hamas lack the technological capability to defeat conventional militaries, effectively serving as expendable geopolitical pawns. - [40:04] A widespread domestic fatigue with theocratic rule in Iran has created an undercurrent favoring secular democracy, hampered only by a fragmented opposition. - [1:01:46] Political Islamist movements, including the Muslim Brotherhood, weaponize religious caliphate narratives as top-down branding instruments solely to secure political power. - [1:19:57] Real-world governance and technological problems must be solved using empirical scientific truths rather than theological truths, which belong strictly in personal spiritual faith. - [1:34:49] Arab states are shifting toward the Abrahamic Accords because internal economic development and stability take precedence over legacy animosities with Israel. ## Chapters 0:00 Introducing Syed Akbar Ali and Malaysia's Trajectory 11:30 Middle Eastern Ground Zero and Global Impact 14:55 Evaluating the Iran-Israel Military Dynamic 34:38 Prospects and Obstacles for Iranian Regime Change 43:31 Origins and Mechanics of Political Islamism 1:14:47 Western Assimilation and the Clash of Civilization 1:18:15 Differentiating Scientific Truth from Religious Truth 1:30:27 Abrahamic Accords and the Shifting Arab Psychology ## Transcript [0:00] Welcome to the latest edition of the God Chart podcast. Sam and I have honestly the really a huge privilege and a pleasure today to welcome um what is in essence I think one of Malaysia's in fact probably Malaysia's most famous and well- read social and political uh bloggers of of recent years. I'm referring of course to site Akbar Ali uh writer of outside the box uh the blogger and Sam you you actually you and I have been reading his blog for ages now and you got particular reference to his background and and and what he's done in the past right? [0:29] Yeah. Uh I think we've known each other for more than 10 years. uh he he he started out he started out as a as a as a banker for for more than a decade and uh he became then a business owner and and a writer and uh he writes completely different than everybody else. uh his audience I would say he appeals to the most intelligent part of our audiences [0:57] which makes me think why are you and I well why am I right right and um um the um uh part of his interesting biography to a was he was also appointed in 2013 uh at the let me uh what what they call the consultation and corruption prevention panel which advises our Malaysian anti anti-corruption commission, right? Um he's well known for his uh blog as you as you said and his book I I I his most uh to me personally I his most famous and uh book and uh interesting take is uh titled Malaysia and the club of doom the collapse of the Islamic countries which was published in 20 2006 and it was [1:46] ceremoniously uh banned in 2016 by the government which means it was bloody good. Yes, it is. So, um I think without further ado, um maybe say it, let's u uh say a few words as a intro on your [2:04] Thank you. your background. Thank you. Yeah. Well, it was unceremoniously banned in uh 2016. Yeah. The book was out of print by then. Ah, cuz I wrote the book in 206. um you know a book will run for a couple of years then you know the sales will drop off. So by 2016 the book was actually out of print and uh only a few of the bookshops still had it. So when they banned it was basically not not on the shelves anymore kind of late you know like after the horses have bolted [2:38] they ran to close the barn. So if you ask something uh uh about me to introduce myself uh I think I'm known now as a blogger. Yeah. Uh as a writer, been writing for a long time. Uh yes, I was a banker. A very interesting uh period of my life. Uh I used to work in project finance and loan syndications. So all those big projects that Malaysians don't like or which we are burdened with, I had a big hand in financing all those projects including the toll highways, the um the power private power plants and all that. Those were that was my game in those days. But [3:19] u I wrote a couple of newspaper columns for some time. I wrote in Bita Mingu a column in Malay uh on Sundays and I wrote a column called human rights in the sun newspaper in English. Then the prime minister changed. My old good friend Tun Dr. Mah retired and uh the new prime minister came on board and I lost both my columns. So I had this itch for writing and I write a lot. So then I wrote my first book I see [3:49] 205 uh to digress a little and then from there I went on to write Malaysia and the club of doom and then uh a third book called the things in common and then I wrote another book called uh relevance and the last one was kafir who [4:05] okay so those are my books and then uh of course uh I was much very much into blogging. I've been doing it for some time. I've been on social media for a long time. So, people know me now as a blogger. Uh so, yes, I do have a audience. People do listen to what I say. I get feedback, things like that. And so, I'm here today. [4:27] All right. I think the question is the why. I mean, you know, obviously people who do there's many of us who who work in the corporate world and who do have these, you know, employment and and and businesses, but very few of us feel um passionate enough to really take a stand and not only write books, but do it consistently and for the very very long term. I think the real question here is the why. [4:47] Yeah. I mean, uh there's everybody has some kind of a motivation, some kind of a drive. I basically um am interested in well like the old sages you know to improve to better make things better uh and especially in our country now. So we we live here. We are all here together in this uh in this boat. And then uh we have to look for the future. Uh and I do see things that are less than good or things that are not so right happening uh the last more than 20 years. And uh as I wrote in my book Malaysia and the Club of Doom, uh Malaysia and the Club of Doom, one of the things that um you [5:29] have to realize that it takes decades for societies to go this way or that way. Whatever you do uh in at a national level at societal level it's going to take you if if you if you tweak with an education policy it's going to take you 30 years 40 years before you realize that we have done the right thing or oops you know we have messed up you see so I think we are we are collecting quite a few oops in this country [5:59] it's going to take time before they we can see some of the results that are happening now the the sluggish growth and things like that uh is anyone happy with our education system? You know, it's getting I think it's getting worse now. [6:12] Uh a lot of things are sort of unraveling. The latest now is the the health health crisis. Health health crisis, the health system. So, uh this is these things didn't start yesterday. Uh it started as I said decades ago. just that I feel that I don't know maybe I'm just a critic or pessimist or whatever but I've been observing these things for a long time. So I like to you know wave the red flag. Uh uh sadly you know unfortunately uh a lot of things that I've been saying have come true. Uh I'm not saying I'm some kind of a prophet but for example I wrote the book [6:54] the club of doom collapse of the Islamic countries in 206 2011 was the Arab spring where basically the Arab countries uh collapsed the system collapsed and they have not recovered since then. So um it doesn't take rocket science if you just you know keep your eyes open and you listen to what people are saying and doing you can you can get a good feel of where things are headed. So that was uh one of the reasons why I've been writing uh for so long and I think I've been consistent. Some people might even say boring cuz I keep repeating the same things. [7:35] But some of these things need to be repeated because uh you have to people have to be aware. It's not something they they should or they can't hear only just once and then uh you don't talk about it anymore. Oh, I think you have to keep repeating it. M I think that Chong I think that that goes neatly into um where we want to first talk about um because I think as as we always mention our uh our Gutshot podcast we we want to hit uh the current news um in the global media uh of what is happening around the world and uh from the perspective of uh uh Asian uh thinking uh with a corporate [8:30] in business background and especially for people like myself and say who came from the Muslim background right so we have deep understanding and we I would say if you read say's blog he's very objective in the way how he analyzes thing right and that goes to the point that you were making um I mean you predicted the slide uh in 2006 which means that you saw it way beyond 2000 way before 2006 right what for what is happening um today you saw it coming already you know almost two dec more than two decades ago I would easily say right am I correct in that assessment [9:14] definitely yeah yeah so what do you think I mean the let's let's go brought first and then we we we focus on on certain areas. I mean, we've had we've had the October 7th uh attack by uh uh Hamas on the state of Israel. Um and then the retaliation that came with it um that sparked this um uh this this this is still currently ongoing in uh in in Gaza. um and then the attack on the Iranian uh nuclear facilities. But actually, if you think about it, Israel went into Iran first even way before that and uh that was a a decapitation of their military capabilities and then basically Trump [10:08] sort of closed out the the uh the nuclear capabilities. Final act. The final act. Exactly. Perfectly put. Um, and now I mean just recently we've got which is actually quite curious. I have not really what which is this the bombing recently in Syria by Israel. So maybe you can pull back to what I just said. Maybe you can take that first which is how you look at what's happening um visav let's take the Iran situation because the news has been pretty quiet um since uh since the attack from uh uh from uh the Trump administration right uh personally I was uh like oh there's not going to be [10:55] a regime change which I think for me um which goes counter to what you already saw. They need a regime change if you ask me, right? But what do you think? How do you look at that current situation? Where do you think that's going? And then maybe we flip to to Gaza and Syria. [11:14] I suppose you don't have many friends in Iran or maybe you do. I don't. Unfortunately, I don't. That's Yeah. Yeah. It's um But your blog has been quite detailed in the way you have you have made assessments of all these uh conflicts. [11:30] Yeah, I I I follow I try to keep up with what is happening in the Middle East every day. It's a huge area and is totally complicated and confusing and confused. Uh the mix of players there is just humongous and uh it is it is a a part of the world that is extremely important. uh to to to backtrack a bit now I am very interested in the Middle East because it has a huge impact on us here as you mentioned both of us are uh Muslims you see so Middle East is identified as the ground zero of uh of Islam and uh whatever happens uh there has a huge bearing on uh Muslims here [12:21] and Muslims throughout the world. you mentioned earlier political Islam all that is linked. So whatever happens in the Middle East uh will definitely have repercussions in Muslim societies around the world. Not just Muslim countries, Muslim societies. If you have uh 50,000 Muslims living somewhere in Birmingham, it's going to affect them too. You see, so it's important to for everybody, not just if you're a Muslim, to keep track of what is happening in the Middle East. Uh because of uh one unfortunate word, uh the word is violence. Unfortunately, you cannot you cannot [13:05] separate this word from a lot of things that are happening in the Middle East and uh with um extremism. They call it jihadism, things like that. It all boils down to violence and it causes problems around the world. So, we have to we have to be aware of this. We in Malaysia have to make sure that we don't import too much of that. [13:28] Unfortunately, it has happened. We have had instances where you know people were involved in uh you know ISIS and all that they were here and then they were arrested by the police and they we had to sort them out and things like that. We are fortunate that we have not suffered any major you know terrorist acts in our country visav Indonesia famous Bali bombing uh other countries of course in Europe and India and Sri Lanka and things like that. So we hope that doesn't happen here but it is constant vigilance you have to keep keep track. So let's get into the quagmire you know the [14:07] right the boiling cauldron in the Middle East. Before you go there can I just add to a bit to what you say it's not just uh how it affects the Muslim society all over the world. Muslim I think the Muslim population is in excess of 2 billion uh in total 1.8 about two. Yeah. Yeah. [14:27] So if you got an extreme elevion, right? So it's it affects includes including wherever uh the Muslim society uh is in place and affects the the surrounding society or countries that they are in place. So that's just a bit additional to what you just said. Yeah. So, [14:55] so the recent the recent uh uh the hostilities between Israel and Iran and uh uh the US bombing of uh Iran. Um this is you see uh uh from a military strategy point of view uh neither country actually is an imminent threat or an existential threat to each other. Imminent threat means something which is going to happen like tomorrow. You know the army the the enemies gathered all their forces and they're going to attack you. It's going to happen tomorrow. They were really not in that situation and neither were they in my view and neither were both of them existential threats. [15:41] Existential threat is something that can happen tomorrow, next month, a year from now. So although the the Iranians have been saying for a long time, death to America, death to Israel and all those things, you know, push the Jews back into the sea. that is sloganering perhaps to satisfy a a domestic audience for their own you know political purposes domestic propaganda just to get the crowds stirred up you know [16:09] right but Iran is 1,600 kilometers from uh Israel across two countries Iraq and uh Jordan Iraq and Syria Iraq and Saudi Arabia you know it's so far away there's no way that countries that so far we are going to be a military threat to each other unless you're going to shoot missiles which they ultimately did but uh neither country is going to be able to invade the other and and and put them out of action. uh although Iran has been saying that they want to liberate the famous alkuds you know the the al axa mosque in uh Jerusalem that is a lot of slogan physically it's [16:49] quite impossible I think it'll be easier for Malaysia to invade the Faulland island because because because there is no land mass between us and the Falton island is 15 20,000 kilometers away we can you know we have two submarines we can we can send it over there and and take over the Falcon Islands and return it back to Argentina, you know, liberate Malvas. [17:14] Malvas, Argentina, assuming we can go, assuming the submarine can actually dive. Okay, go on. That's what I was going to say. But to say that uh Iran can you know physically move forces across the desert 1,600 kilometers and invade uh Israel and chase the Jews back into the sea. It's not going to happen. It's not going to happen. No way. And ne neither do the Jews have any interest. I mean the Israelis have any interest in attacking Iran. What is a military objective? But when you both develop missiles, I mean they both have missiles and then uh Iran started developing [17:56] their nuclear uh capability. Not only uh they well there were a lot of um what do you call this uh dubious things about exactly how they were going about it. There was dispute. They said they're developing nuclear power basically for civilian use. But the Israelis and Americans and the West was not fully convinced about that. But if they had gone ahead and developed nuclear weapons added with the rhetoric, we're going to chase the Jews into the sea, we're going to destroy Israel. That is a a very frightening uh combination. So that's why the Israelis have been saying that [18:37] we will never allow uh belligerent states, enemy states to to get nuclear weapons. So which is why in 1981 they bombed Iraq. Do you remember when they bombed the Iraqi nuclear reactor, the famous Osraq reactor? [18:54] Oh okay. Yeah. 1981 Saddam Hussein was starting a nuclear program. Again it was just a nuclear reactor, a civilian nuclear reactor to make electricity. you you cannot make a nuclear atomic bomb from day one, you know, it takes decades. But the moment Saddam Hussein said he wanted to build a nuclear reactor, they bombed it 1981 before the reactor became hot, before they they commissioned it, before they put the fuel inside, they they bombed it. And then uh early 2000 2007 uh the Syrians built uh nuclear reactor again for power generation and the Israelis bombed it because both Iraq and [19:35] Syria had made it clear that they are enemies of uh Israel that constantly issuing threats and all that. So that the Israelis they don't want to tolerate. Now Saudi Arabia is planning uh nuclear uh nuclear facilities, nuclear reactors and I think UAE if I'm not mistaken but the Israelis are not worried about it because the Saudis and the UAE now are considered they're not enemies. Okay, they may not be 100% buddy buddies. They have not signed the or not yet but nevertheless they are not belligerent. They don't issue threats against Israel every day. So because of [20:14] that, the Israelis uh they're okay. If Saudi Arabia wants to go ahead and develop uh nuclear power plants and all that, they're okay. So which which goes to show that they react uh to threats uh and if they see that it is moving from it is becoming an existential threat, they will take action. You can't let a nuclear uh nuclear capability become an imminent threat. That's too late. [20:39] Exactly. Too late. So uh basically that's what they are. they have said they will do and they're doing. But as you mentioned just now before April 2024, the first Iranian strike against Israel was April 2024. There was no there was no direct conflict between them. There's a lot of saber rattling, a lot of calling names and issuing statements and things like that. But there were the proxy proxy conflict. Uh well, Iran had proxies. Iran had the Hezbollah in Beirut in Lebanon and they had the Palestinian Islamic Jihad and uh the Hamas um was not exactly a proxy of Iran [21:22] because Hamas is Sunnis. They are Muslim Brotherhood whereas Iran is Shia but nevertheless the Iranians were well they were supporting Hamas also you know um but they were using proxies and then later the the Houthis in Yemen joined in the prey. So it was a proxy war using proxies to kind of uh take pot shots at Israel. But then again, you see, even though they had all these proxies, uh the proxies were militia, you know, like Hezbollah, basically teenagers wearing jeans and sneakers running around. Yeah, that's it. They the so-called missiles that they had were [22:08] largely water pipes, steel water pipes. They will fill it in with rocket fuel and attach a warhead there. It's not guided. It doesn't have any kind of electronics. And they physically have to light a fuse, you know, like old American Civil War style. I'm not sure. And then it shoots off and that's it. They also had other capacities because they did bring in gu larger missiles also supplied by Iran which had uh which were more accurate, more lethal. But on the whole it was basically a militia you know run by this uh man by young people you know idealistic youngsters you know [22:48] not very who may not know what exactly is going on and you are pitting this kind of militia against the fourth largest the fourth fourth most powerful military in the world you know without without a doubt the Israeli armed forces defense IDF Israeli defense forces are a very capable military. They have over 600,000 uh personnel active about more than 200,000 reserves about 3 plus 400,000 highly trained and uh equipped armed with uh it's it's a technology game. The highest technology in the world in weapons manufacturing is in the west and also in in Israel and Russia. [23:32] Yeah. you know, I mean, like even 40 years ago in my university, there was a whole bunch of uh Israeli students actually and um they just looked like all of us, right? Um late teens, early 20s, but by that time they were already like one, two years older than us. And they had been trained in they were tank commanders. They were jet fighter pilots. They were trained to, you know, handtohand combat. They knew how to handle pistols, rifles, um martial arts. And they could have killed any one of us Malaysians, honestly. So he said, "We better not piss any I I want to just interject your your [24:06] story because it's very fascinating you I don't want to interrupt your flow of thought but I had a I had a question quick one uh on these proxies right apart from um basically Hamas or his which can um I mean which has a direct uh threat to you know acts of terrorism uh uh against the Jews. and the Israelis. Um, the rest are just it's just too far away. The Houthis are shooting merchant ships, you know. I really don't understand the game plan of Iran in a sense. I really don't, as you rightly put. Um and then it's an unwinable thing to go you know for the his bulock and [24:58] the and the hamasses that you know which even the PLO was vanquished right so now we have this uh and and now they are being chopped off so what what is this whole point [25:12] yeah yeah so that's a very good point because um for someone like me who's non-Muslim and actually doesn't really care much about politics Right. But we have to care because as you said it affects everybody. Right. So the question is I think what Sam is trying to say why is Iran I mean for for the for example why is it what's Iran's why right? What is it one? What's it intentions? [25:33] Yeah that's why as I said you know they have the the military strategy point of view is it's not there. It's it's zero. Iran can never invade or uh overthrow Israel and neither can the proxies. as I'm saying I'm I'm I was comparing the strength comparison [25:51] but you said with such certainty right I mean what makes you so sure they can't do it no uh so far they have not been able to but let me finish your point on the on the military uh the recent action between Israel and Iran was aerial aerial warfare the Israelis sent their jet fighters and the Iranians uh shot missiles nearly all the the missiles and drones phone sent by Iran didn't hit their targets. There were some, but mostly all did not. But the Israelis were able to achieve a higher heat rate. It was almost one to one. Uh they launch bombs and missiles and rockets or whatever and [26:33] the targets were all hit. So the the military capability of is is is very highly imbalanced. Uh as you said, the Israelis, they've been training their whole life. You know, they're highly trained. Israeli Air Force pilots fly minimum 6 hours every week. US Air Force pilots fly 1 to 3 hours a week, 3 hours. Most other air forces are like that. So, these fellas fly 6 hours a week minimum. So, they are like razor sharp, you know. So, you're not going to be able to defeat uh these people uh in in the Middle East, Hisba and Iran and Hamas. And we have seen that happening now. It [27:14] was basically to me a suicidal mission. Uh his bullah's chief Hassan Nasola has been killed. All the Hamas leadership has been wiped out. His bullah is basically uh they have been defeated in uh in Beirut in Lebanon. They are down to bare bones. Hamas is also on the on the uh seriously degraded. They're not really a potent force anymore. They have basically been sacrificed. So what was the purpose in doing this? Yeah, that's why I keep saying that uh it is more for domestic optics and domestic propaganda in Iran for the ayatollas to keep their people uh to to motivate or to uh what do you [28:03] call this to galvanize support from their own people because they have their own problems in their local domestic politics. Their popularity is not exactly very high in Iran. The Ayatollas u you it is highly debatable how popular they are in Iran. And there are people who say that which I tend to agree that they are not so popular and this regime can be uh if the conditions are right they can be overthrown any time. More importantly there is a very strong undercurrent in Iran that wants change. So all these things that are happening in the Middle East, you know, they spend [28:45] money on Houthis and Hezbollah is for the optics and the propaganda back home in Iran to tell the Iranian people that, you know, they are doing something. They are fighting for Islam. They're going to liberate Palestine. [28:58] Yeah. They're the champions of Islam. Champions of Islam. They and they and they they back up Shia Shia groups outside of Iran. Uh his Shia, the Houthis are Shia, Yemen is Shia. So they want to be seen as the champions of Shia Islam to the Shia people inside Iran because Iran is majority Shia. So that is the only logical objective I see in Iran doing all this because militarily [29:27] it makes no sense. Zero. It's zero. You're not going to drive the Jews into the sea. Not with teenage militia wearing jeans and sneakers. No way. You are sacrificing them, which is what has happened. They've all been sacrificed. Uh but unfortunately uh because they spend money. So money does buy support. Money buys guns. Yeah. [29:50] Yeah. So the the reason is ultimately power consolidation and staying in power essentially to be relevant. To be relevant in to appear relevant, but you just want to retain power, right? I mean just to stay in authority. There's no real democracy in uh in Iran which is the other point maybe I want to discuss later when you ask about Middle East you know the big picture [30:13] there's there are no democratic countries at all in the whole of the Middle East even Tunisia are supposed to be democratic I think they're having problems too but the Middle East from the extreme east to the west it is it is either authoritarian or dictatorship or monarchy there's no democratic country in the Middle The the Ayatalas say that they are democratic. But no no no one believes that because the president is chosen from a pool which is nominated by the the supreme leader. If the Ayatollah doesn't uh agree with the candidate to run for president, they [30:50] have a few only a few then you can't run for president. So only those who are endorsed by the ayatah the supreme leader he runs for president in Iran. But the supreme leader himself is not elected. He's for life. He's elected once, appointed once and he remains for life. The president Ayatah Ali Kamei has been there for what 36 years or something. [31:11] You could equally say that China has no democracy as well and it's authoritarian. Uh why but but why does China have a different economic situation? Uh no, I beg to defer. China has uh it's a it's a authoritarian. It's a centralized government. uh it is uh well communism not mean it is uh authoritarian but China is authoritarian centralized government but to say that they are not democratic is uh debatable because uh in China the uh the what do you call this they mingle with the the the people down to the village level this concept of town hall meetings and [31:49] all that is is a big thing in China uh whenever they want to do something they really discuss things down to the the town hall and the village level where people do express their agreements, disagreements and so on what not. uh the government usually, okay, one negative thing is that the government usually uses these uh meetings or this you know town councils to tell people uh to tell them not to talk down to them but they also get feedback and uh they do not they do not uh ignore the feedback [32:24] when they were building that dam that huge dam seven gorgeous they shifted like I don't know what couple of million people or something like that you know and It happened quite smoothly and very well done. There were no serious protests because the government from way before they explained step by step what we're going to do. We're going to move you. We building new uh you know uh of course they have the money to do things. We're going to build new houses for you and everything. So it was they manage it well so they get feedback. Uh you don't find this in the in the Middle East. So [32:59] let's let's take back to uh the Iranian situation, right? Um I think even though it is Shia even in the majority even in the majority um uh Islamic Sunni population uh they seem to uh become like um uh like a flag bearer of uh the Islamic cause so to speak um within the mindset of uh of uh Muslim in general. Um so but like you said um the popularity of the Iranian ayatah regime is really not there. Some predate that actually their support is even less than 30%. [33:48] I wouldn't dispute that. Yeah. Yeah. So um why I thought that actually the condition for regime change was quite ripe if the the the action were to continue uh within Iran. uh that would liberate u the majority of the people because let's not uh you know like like you say it's about technology at the end of the day and in Iran the technology so to speak is held by the Iranian um uh what do you call that the the the revolutionary guards they are the one holding the the machine guns right so you really can't expect when a regime holds the m the the guns the up for people uprising to be [34:38] successful and that's what happened in Arab Spring in my opinion partly as well. So what do you say about about them where do they go from here you think? Yeah, I mean the exact the exact situation perhaps existed in Iran at the time of the sha [34:56] was much more powerful you know you had the security services sabak and all that and same thing you know any resistance any rebellion anywhere they would they would come down hard on them but ultimately when people were had nothing more to lose they they overthrew the sha I think the same thing will happen to the the the Iranian people Now, uh, one of the one of the, uh, outcomes of this attack, this Israeli attack in Iran is that, uh, the IRGC was has been proven to be much less than what they were thought to be in terms of their capacity. They have been degraded [35:37] substantially. And just yesterday, I'm sorry, Wednesday, I was listening to the uh podcast coming out uh Iranian podcast coming out outside Iran where they report and they show videos of explosions in Thran on Wednesday, multiple explosions at IRGC related uh offices, homes and structures like that. So there's still some kind of this somebody's doing a lot of sabotage work on the ground, but actually there's a ceasefire between Israel and Iran. It only lasted 12 days and it was more than a month ago. So there are other people now on the ground in Thran who are [36:17] carrying out the sabotage activities. And uh it's it's headed somewhere. I I it's difficult to say now how or where it is going. But one of the things that the Israeli prime minister said is that there is going to be a regime change in Iran. Uh Ben Netanyahu has said that. So um maybe they are working with the Americans on something. I I don't know. But the fact is that there are still explosions and things like that going on in Thran as late as Wednesday. So uh I really do know what's going to happen. Um the Iranian airspace is still closed. Uh people don't realize this a lot. You [36:57] know, since the the thing started, the hostility started on June 13th. Iranian airspace practically been closed. All the international flights are rrooted. Uh it is not by the Iranians. I think uh they have been told to avoid the Iran. The Iranian airspace is closed. Thran airport is down to like bare bones operation. uh the significance is that uh this may embarrass the regime if there are no flights coming into Kerala for a month or two months. People ask what's going on to the country is a major embarrassment. So Iranian airspace is closed. So I really don't know what's [37:34] going to happen in Iran uh soon but I think uh some maybe something is cooking. We really don't know. M uh so yes they use force definitely they only have force to come down hard on the people remember when that young girl was killed [37:51] Masa Armenia 2022 I think there were serious riots and protests street demonstrations throughout Iran they were actually quite shaken by that because the turnouts were were big the only thing why the regime change didn't happen then and even now is that there is no clear-cut organized opposition waiting to take over. If the if the Ayatah regime falls tomorrow, who's going to be the the leader? There are there are few people who are who are prepared, but they are outside the country. One is a crown prince, the former Sha son. His name is uh crown prince Raza Raza Palabi. Uh he's about [38:35] our age now, 60s and something. and uh he seems ready to to step in to provide the leadership but not everybody in Iran uh may support him. Uh and then there is that lady her name is Mariam Rajabi. She's also has significant support but among exiled Iranians and uh so the the issue now is who can step in and take over Iran who can organize organized the resistance that is a blank space there which is why that regime change is not happening uh or it's not there's no one there to to lead on the ground. So this either this situation has to change [39:18] and whoever is planning a regime change in Iran has to fill in this blank. You must provide a name, a figurehead, a person. Yeah. Somebody to rally around and they must have a platform and then they must have people on the ground in Iran [39:32] to to uh to pave the way to make things ready and then the regime change can happen. Otherwise, let's say tomorrow there's a lucky strike and they take out the the ayatas and all that then who's going to take over the country? So, I think that is why they have not taken out the ayatah. They have not tried to decapitate him because uh then he might throw the whole country into [39:58] chaos. Major chaos. Yeah. What in your opinion is what the Iranian people themselves want? I know you say it's a huge country and it's very disparit but generally speaking uh I think uh is it is it is clearer I mean they all want a free country just like anybody else they want freedom they want democracy but more clearer now in Iran for a Islamic country is what they don't want uh religion is extremely unpopular now in Iran it may grow it may go from if there's a regime change it may grow go from a theocracy to the extreme uh the other side 100% secular popular democracy or even anti- [40:37] theocracy, anti- relligion because a lot of people there are they are extremely tired and uh they have been let down by the way religion has been used against them. So they are they are very clear on what they do not want. What they want is I think u democracy you know multi-party system and all that. They have had some experience because they do have scheduled elections in Iran but as I said presidential elections but as I as I said the candidates are handpicked by the they have to be endorsed by the moolas so that restricts their democracy and the supreme leader does not change [41:15] but they they are used to well they know the system you know of of putting a vote in a ballot box and waiting for the outcome. I think they all want that. Uh the Iranian people want that. And uh uh authority authoritarian systems, theocracies uh past tense, past tense. [41:36] Having having said that, maybe um I I I want to slide into um the Muslim world. Um and uh I have a theory or thesis. I would like you to see where you think uh on this because um Muslim society let's say in Malaysia where we are relatively comfortable right we don't have wars we have jobs I mean it's uh I mean the the mass of the society may not be in a great situation uh or going much greater as you rightly put at the beginning um because of the policies of uh decades but um we're pretty comfortable relatively comfortable Indonesia to a certain extent um which has the biggest Muslim [42:35] population in a country um you've got you know um uh in western countries as well um Muslim societies um but somehow or other they uh seem to be almost yearning for theocracy or theocratic leadership and that's goes to your club of doom thesis right um I had a thought in my mind uh of the origins of this which is um the catalytic is uh the Muslim Brotherhood um uh birth in Egypt and then um it was put on steroids when Kmeni take power in Iran because I saw that when you and I were going to university uh in the US and how far that reach of that kind of thinking with [43:31] respect to the revivalism of Islam and this this thought of having an a Muslim caliphate uh in in in all this all these Muslim countries to start off with and expansion that goes back then maybe excuse me if I go slightly longer go on this disease for you to respond. I thought it it reminded me when I was very when we were very young um how uh religious classes were taught and uh and how anti-semitism was planted into the minds of young Muslims. When you don't even know there exist a state of Israel, you were thought that uh uh that that Jews were enemies of the prophet. they [44:18] were the one who turned their backs on him in Medina and continued throughout the um uh and and that is repeated to you. So when they they they come of age and then they see also um and they are uh put into a propagandistic situation where uh the state of Israel is seen as being um uh being a colonial entity on the on the on the Arab world, right? And imposed upon an uh on the Arab world. Um the reaction is visceral. However, I used to point out to to to to my friends and I said, "We seem to forget that Jerusalem was never uh a Muslim uh territory. It was after the fact of the Islamic [45:16] caliphate that that we the Muslims were the original colonialist if you were to ask and the consequences of war. In any case, the Muslim took the Muslim empire took hold of that and the vestigages of that Muslim empire was the uh was the Ottoman as the last one that lost the war uh the first world war already and the British became the western power that took over the region. So war has consequences over the whole arc of history. So the question then becomes is that hey if you lost your war accept the consequences move forward like Japan did like how Germany did and look at what [45:58] they are today but the uh the Muslim world or that uh seem to be unable to move from that kind of thinking uh and it's you know it's it's it's fueled as well because of the uh the thought of the holiest site being Jerusalem. right by two mukadis. So they cannot move out of this paradigm because of the theocratic thinking. what is so then we maybe you can comment on that and then let's see whether we we we can come to uh whether we agree or disagree and then um how the whole Palestinian situation is uh is to me actually I see being used by political powers whether that be the [46:50] PLO then comes Hasbollah or Hamas more for their own political power to continue the fight, you know, and the and Iran having them as proxies to retain their power in Iran. So I I I I at that point I I I would like to hear your [47:09] I think they were they reply that if you have been sitting on a piece of property for more than 500 years, all the previous history is forgotten. You are the owner. But you have a point there. I mean uh uh uh you see uh the Muslims they invaded Jerusalem in 635 or 638 [47:31] Omar the prophet died in 632 and 638 they invaded they captured Jerusalem and then after that 6 uh 650s and 670s they took the whole of North Africa all the way to Morocco And uh I think it was around that time the 650s 670s they crossed the straits of Gibralta and took uh Spain Spain took about 50 years to the Iberian Peninsula by se excuse me by 732 which is 100 years after the prophet was the famous battle of tours in in in France battle of tours which is a suburb of Paris I think it's outside of Paris. Yeah, I've been there. [48:16] But they lost. But the Muslims were stopped by Frank Charles Martell. What if they had won all the way to Paris and so today Paris will be part of the Islamic they will be talking Arab [48:28] and they'll say that uh it's been there for more than 500 years. You know, you can't question it anymore. It belongs to us. So you are right. History is just how long you hold the territory. So maybe if you wait another 500 years, the argument will go away. But but uh and then it took the the in the 600s and up to 700s they invaded North Africa, Spain and went into stop with the battle of tourism. It took the Europeans uh 400 years the first crusade was 1,000 and something AD the first century 1,00 something AD. So it took more almost 400 years for the Europeans to [49:12] react after the Muslim invasions of uh Spain and into France and also they tried along the the other corridor going up through Turkey but Anatolia was uh they were all approaching from the from the east also but Spain had fallen so and of course Jerusalem. So it took the Europeans uh about 400 years before they organized the first uh crusade. Uh it was started after the the Muslim invasions of u u Jerusalem, North Africa. But today the argument is it happened so long ago you know it's ours now. Too bad. But um but the thing is uh the claims have not uh really uh gone away uh especially in [50:03] Israel because of these people called the Jews who also claim uh to come from there. Uh I mean historically they have been there just as a as a side remark you know in uh Muslims the name for Jerusalem is Bul Mukadis. Bal Mukadis. B means house. Mukadis means holy, sacred, sacred house. Mukadis, this is actually a Hebrew word, you know, [50:32] the irony of ironies in Hebrew. Yeah. Uh you know the temple, the Jewish temple. The first temple was built by Solomon, it's there in Jerusalem. And then the second temple was built at the same I think it's about there. [50:45] It was destroyed by the Germans in AD70 uh by the Romans in AD70. But the the the footings, all the the foundations are still there and now they're planning to rebuild again. But anyway, the Jewish temple is it's a it's a kind of rectangular structure, you know, it's a very huge courtyard and right in the center is a little cubicle, the sacred holy of holies, like you know the ka in uh in Makkah. uh they have a a holy of holies the sacred it's a cubicle building where they do the sacrifices and things like that and that building the holy of holies in Hebrew is ba mikdash [51:28] the house that is sacred mikdash in Hebrew in Arabic is mkadis so so the name has remained the name has been maintained uh in a way you know acknowledging that there is a Jewish president to this name. Bal Mukadis is BA Mikdash. So do [51:50] you know what right guys um for someone like me who actually I I openly profess not having any faith either. No. Right. So I I don't really like politics. I don't really have a faith and I don't even see myself as really Chinese. So the things I'm I feel like an outsider all the time. Right. But it seems to me that for people who live in that region which has sprouted three great faiths right which of all have a holy book there and there's so much in terms of overlap between cultures and and and and idiosyncrasies and likes and dislikes it could so easily have been much more [52:23] peaceful and and smooth right um so I mean I think it's it's a bit too late for that now water has too much water has passed under the bridge what what happens from here on in and I think the so what matters you know for for the rest of the Well, um where does it go? What what is your interpretation of the temperature now? [52:40] The it's it's it's as I said, you know, the Middle East is a huge place. It's it's still confused by legacy issues, cultural issues basically. Uh religious issues and then you have um uh you have racial identities. [52:58] For example, you got the Drews, the Kurds, the Arabs, the Persians, the Armenians, Turks. uh racial identity, linguistic identity and then you have uh religious identities. The Muslims, the Muslims are Shia, Sunnis, and you got the Christians, you have the Jews. Uh you have the Drews who are very unique religion by themselves and things like that. All these are legacies. They cannot uh it is still important for them. That's why it's is causing a lot of issues for people. They cannot unite. uh some countries uh I'm talking about Muslim countries are trying to change [53:34] that I think uh uh Saudi Arabia Muhammad bin Salman he's doing a lot of changes or he has done a lot of things in the country uh okay you can debate depending on what is your own background you can debate whether what he's doing is right or what he's doing is wrong but he he is making a lot of changes from where Saudi Arabia was before women can now drive cars they can work they can go out on their they can leave the country on their own travel alone by themselves. Um so uh that those are major changes in Saudi Arabia whether you agree or disagree whether you are a Saudi or [54:10] Sunni or whatever the point is these changes have been made. So once the changes have been made and they've been around for like 10 years now it's very hard to go back. Yeah. But you also lay down the principle that change can be made even in an impossible country like Saudi Arabia. You can have drastic change. And then you have other countries like UAE uh which is going further ahead than Saudi Arabia. Uh the UAE is actually extremely well they're very secular and uh they they have sort of their own heritage you know especially the religious heritage is um is they're not [54:48] really hard up about it. they're not paranoid about it. So there are these changes happening in uh in the Middle East uh which hopefully uh people will start pondering. Not saying that everybody should follow the Saudi model but that you can make changes. Uh but certainly going the way they are does not solve their problems especially uh it actually creates more problems. Like now the fighting in Syria is between the Drews and the Sunnis and it's purely racial you know because the Drews are a people they are not really Muslim they are they're a hybrid they are amalgam of [55:26] Christianity Judaism and Islam you know it's a unique religion and of course the Sunnis in in Syria now don't like them the Sunnis they are basically Salapis the fanatic type jihadis so there's a clash now in as we speak in Syria and yesterday and day before I think the Israeli army went in to uh help to sort things out but there's still fighting going on but this is the legacy these are the legacy issues in the Middle East. [55:53] Yeah. So what you're talking about in terms of the developments in in in Emirates as well as in Saudi right speaks a lot to what Sam has been uh speaking about the last couple of episodes without you around which is to say which is to say that there seems to be two paradigms developing in the Middle East. One is the paradigm being developed by NBS and and the cohorts who seem to be moving towards libertarianism more more egalitarianism more freedoms and all that and it's my belief as a person right that I think everybody wants to be free everybody wants to have [56:21] have independence everybody wants to have a certain kind of autonomy which is very appealing in terms of what Saudis are doing right agree or agree or disagree the young seem to like it of course of course who doesn't want to be free right [56:34] the only problem I see actually everywhere is that when people in political power uh Islamist in mind uh or uses the religion to hold on to power, their motivation is to indoctrinate the people to be more to be more theocratically inclined in how they run their daily lives [57:02] with the end goal being subjugation. The end goal being to have uh really um uh not not the word subjugation comes later. Obedience. Yes. More towards I I would call it um I would call it to to to to make them being sheep. [57:22] Sheep. Yeah. I mean I'm trying to find a better follower to be to be able to be malleable to the political power using uh uh Islam as a tool [57:34] and the pathway is is the mental capture. Correct. So I I so I want to take sight back to where he was uh going at uh in the now within the Palestinian Israel uh issue to to to that extent to that extent because I read his column um on uh on the leadership of Hamas and how they were jetting around you know using all this Muslim country contribution living in Switzerland drive going private jet while their people suffer and and um and are being used as tools whilst they live a good life. You know, they live a modern life [58:17] and their people and their people are being fed that uh that they're fighting for freedom, you know. So, where do you think why where do you think the endgame is going to be now that we have seen? I mean October 7 was really makes no sense to me. It was it was you know that the retaliation is going to be severe right almost like [58:46] I I wonder I wonder the same thing as well. I mean why do this because you know there's going to be retaliation. Yeah. And and yet if you come to I mean our the way the the the Muslim and also in the far east how much they condemn Israel right? Look, if you poke the hornet's nest, you're going to get it. The same thought I had when September 11 happened. I said, and and I was seeing this whole thing in the Muslim world, uh, you know, that they've taken down the the superpower, right? But I said, you guys are delusional because the the the blowback that is going to [59:28] come is going to be monumental. the only losers are going to be the Muslims. So in the same sense actually I think October 7 was a watershed for the for for for for Israel Palestine uh region and how things are going to move on from there on because I don't I think Israel has said enough is enough and they're going for the kill. All right. I I I don't know. And and so my my throw to you is where do you see the endgame? How do you think this progressed? Say [1:00:06] yeah, it was a suicide mission on hindsight. On hindsight, just like 9/11, it was literally a suicide mission. They flew the planes into the building and committed suicide. This one as you mentioned Hamas and Hzbollah and which we discussed earlier uh Hassan Hbollah has been killed is honey has been killed the Hamas leadership has been killed his bullah has been wiped out Hamas has been defeated I mean why poke the hornets's nest why go and poke the elephant you know he can stomp on you but that's what has been done uh so it was someone else's agenda a lot of [1:00:47] these things that we say are Islamic around the Middle East and around the world. They are not inherent by themselves. They do not come up on their own. You know, it's not like everybody all the Muslims want we want to establish an Islamic caliphate. No, it is somebody's agenda, some group, some political grouping, somebody who wants to looking for their own political survival. So they create agendas and they ride it like um Arab Spring. Arab Spring was a Muslim Brotherhood agenda. They were they were they were they were they had a lot of support from Obama. A [1:01:25] Muslim Brotherhood was not was you know they were they had some backing from the Obama and Clinton Obama administration and uh the Arab Spring happened. Arab Spring was basically a Muslim Brotherhood game because Tunisia was taken over by the Nahada party which was Muslim Brotherhood party. Morsi was a Muslim Brotherhood guy. [1:01:46] Erdogan Erdogan is Muslim Brotherhood. Yeah. So the Muslim Brotherhood uh their flag was flying high for a while but then they couldn't sustain it. They couldn't move the people forward and they were they lost. They were taken out. Uh Morsi was overthrown by the army. So now they're back. But it was an agenda and the agenda of the Muslim Brotherhood was to establish caliphate and this and that. But it is it is it is a means to an end. What they want is they want power. So why not use religion Islam? People are already Muslims and uh you know there are issues with the west, [1:02:23] issues with Islamic countries being behind and uh the west you know lording over over the rest of the world. So these are all uh lowhanging fruit. Package it in a nice little package, paint it green, you know, put a Islamic sticker on it, you know, and sell it and people will buy it. Is what they're doing. Same thing with Iran. Uh when the Ayatollah took over Iran, of course, the the Sha of Iran at the time and his regime, they provided a lowhanging fruit. There was a lot of oppression going on. There were a lot of unhappy people in Iran. Not everybody was rich, [1:02:55] people were poor. And uh so the sha the ayatah came and he promised religion and the second coming and this and that you know uh packaged it in a nice religious package and they took over Iran. Then they realized that they can't deliver you know they just same equal as the sha uh just like the Muslim Brotherhood and other Islamic movements they couldn't deliver anything uh new in in the Middle East or Islamic countries. So now uh what's going to happen? They are not going to be able to achieve much on their own. We actually need to talk about the Abrahamic accords. But you [1:03:29] please please. Yeah. So now the Middle Eastern countries have realized that from from the time Israel was set up 1948 until 7378 Cam David of course 1978 and then post Cam David uh don't forget 1994 there was a president of Palestine Yasir Arafat became president of Palestine talking about two states all there was the the second state was there Yasir Arafat was a president of Palestine people forget 1994 he became president of Palestine and president of the West Bank and Gaza and he was president until he died in 2004. So for 10 years there was a president of Palestine of a unified [1:04:14] Palestine Gaza and West Bank. After he died things went uh as went chaotic. the PLO was uh uh remain took uh West Bank and the Hamas people moved into Gaza. They were already there but they won in the elections they won more seats. Hamas won more seats in Gaza and the PLO Fatah won more seats in the West Bank. So they sort of became two separate countries. It's now shoot on site. It's been shoot on site since then. If the amas sees the the PLO guys, the Fatah guys shoot on site. They're not they're the total enemies. So now you see that West Bank does not [1:04:55] shoot rockets into Israel. They sort of it's not that they they they fallen in love with the Israelis. No, but they find that you know they don't want to shoot rockets. They don't they don't see it as a means to achieve anything. [1:05:07] Did did you see it's a quick one? Did you see that there was overures from tribal leaders in West Bank to Israel? The the Mktars. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. So uh back to Gaza because Gaza Hamas is Muslim Brotherhood and Muslim Brotherhood have their own agenda. Muslim Brotherhood is a huge organization. They operate in nearly all Muslim countries. As you said, Turkey Ardugan is a strong supporter of in fact he's a Khalifa of uh Muslim Brotherhood. So uh wherever there is an Islamic struggle per se, there is there are agendas behind it. It is driven top down. Somebody wants power. [1:05:47] Yeah. They want, you know, power, money, politics, whatever. And they use religion. They package it in whatever. If you are a Shia, if you're Ayatah, you package it in a Shia packaging, you know, Shia Islam. Uh, and then you have the Muslim Brotherhood with their version of Islam. They package it and all that. And then when the ISIS guys came up after 2013, theirs was basically Wahhabism, Salafism. So that was a very violent uh uh version of uh religion which they presented and they found their supporters and until they were militarily defeated by good old [1:06:21] President Donald Trump. Uh so every time there's an agenda that moves these uh Islamic uh groups and this quest for caliphate and all that it does not come from the ground up. From the ground up I think Muslims are just like any other people on this surface of this earth. We just want to go about our daily chores and go about, you know, taking care of our families, paying for the house, paying for the car, getting the kids educated, living in a safe environment, it is no same. I mean, if you if you travel the world, you talk to people in the street, we're all the same, right? And the color of [1:06:57] your skin is literally like three micrometers thick, right? So, I mean, if people have that perspective and realize they've been productized and packaged messaging, too, right? And it's not as if, you know, you're like incredibly much more intelligent by 50 or 50 60 IQ than the next guy, right? [1:07:14] Why don't people have that perspective? I mean, if someone as dumb as me cannot like, oh, I've been I've been lied to for ages, right? You know, you're not dumb. That's the problem. It's not as if I'm so much more smart than the next guy. You know what I mean? there there are certain uh entrenched entrenched uh uh [1:07:32] it seems to me it's because people feel so strongly about the tribe that they belong to. So in this case the tribe is this faith called whatever it's going to be. Do you know what I mean? So you see the same crazies in America. You see the same crazies in South America [1:07:45] is magnified by the vested interest wherever you go anywhere in the world. It's magnified by by the vested interest. the politicians in power or the power the authoritarians in power they use this religion to to safeguard their own position. So they need to create you know tensions and hatreds and all kinds of debates and arguments which are counterproductive actually but to them it helps them to secure their position that that's it's just politics because otherwise you see nowadays the Muslim countries have a lot of problems and you find that a lot of people who [1:08:19] leave Islamic countries right and they are refugees and where do they go do they go to another Muslim country? No, they go to Europe. They go to Yeah. They go to France. Discuss that. Can what I mean is so chop chop chop. Last night on Sky News Australia, they were showing a 10-minute documentary clip, Sam, of riots, immigrant riots in not just not just in France, in Spain, in Germany, in the UK, right? There's vast amounts of of town-based domestic crime between immigrant uh hordes of immigrants, usually from, you know, Muslim Muslim countries, right, with the local [1:08:52] populace. And you quite rightly point out why don't they come and live in Malaysia or Indonesia? Why? Well, the funny thing is they go to the western country and they are culturally not adaptive mentally to um uh uh to assimilate with that culture. That's one problem. Then the other problem again within their society they will have you see you only need about let's say 20 to 30% of extreme thought and leadership especially you know that fermentss violence and the the the the need to hold power like what say was mentioning okay it is not it's is the violent [1:09:35] minority that actually takes control of the society because the rest of us just want to go and make a living. Yeah. Right. But the but but the the the the leadership the political leadership are the ones that is fermenting this because the minority that they can control is the one that is the loudest the one that is going to impinge on the rights of others and the rights then and that's how they take control. Now may I I just go back to MBS just for a short while which is I am a pretty big fan of what MBS is doing. Okay. Because I believe that the only way to change a theocratic [1:10:18] based society is top down. It cannot be bottom up. It doesn't work work right. And I went to Dam last 20 in 2020 before the COVID lockdown. I was actually shocked because I was visiting my staff who were operating there and uh and I I mean the they were opening up ladies were coming to restaurants and they had no separation like before. Um um and and it was a big difference you know and I saw it vividly. uh and I went to um to a to conference and there were ladies who were no longer in hijabs. So that was never before in in Saudi, right? So you can see palpable [1:11:07] change. That was 5 years ago. So I have not been back yet. So firsthand uh firsthand information, but I think therefore it goes to a certain extent. I think the leadership in that region, especially the Palestinians, whether we like it or not, it will have to come via Israel imposed by America because I don't because the the the the uh uh the political leadership there depends on violence and money coming from the Iranian regime in order to survive. So that's my thought of where that's going, right? So then I think we've discussed this this two part. So let's look at the what effect it has in [1:11:59] western societies in the UK. Uh in America you're talking about in the UK, you know, we have jokes from our friends in the UK that says Birmingham is already an Islamic country, right? Okay. you know they practically I just saw you know this this muty I was like who had an OBBE you know he has no education you know he's a dropout right but run schools in the UK uh Islamic schools and he's been appointed uh as a uh by the government to head the uh standards review board of the UK education. I was like, "What the hell is wrong with the UK?" You know, right? I mean, I myself personally [1:12:53] has been up in arms since the appointments of religious scholars in our education department heading the ministry. I think it's absolute nonsense. You know, those people can't even pass SRP, right? uh you know and have doctors in front of their name but they can't even form cogent sentences. Now you have in America like uh you know where Ilanoma comes from right in Michigan for example. So in Paris the issues that they have in in I think America is just starting to see the problem. Um I think Dallas they will they want to set up an Islamic society only you know can you imagine that have [1:13:44] you heard that news right um in we know in Paris the outskirt of Paris Perth Australia in yeah so I mean how do you see this playing out does the because the west we've been you you were you were in Padu and Oklahoma right and Um you know we see how it is. You go and get there is a culture of of trust in the western society. You put a quarter you open uh the box and you take a piece of newspaper right you the society is trustworthy enough in their culture that you are expected to take for what you buy and that's it. Nobody question it. You try that over here and see what [1:14:32] happens. Right? So you know I think it's a clash of civilization if you ask me. What do you think? I mean how how do you think this is going to play out? I don't think the west understands what they are facing. [1:14:47] It's it's uh the the outlook is totally different. The civilizational outlook, the cultural outlook is different. Which is why these immigrants who go to the west, they face problems. the first generation they face problems adjusting and uh some of them come from very challenge challenging or challenged background so they a lot of u misbehavior or behavior that doesn't fit into the society that they are in so that will take some time but eventually a large the bulk of immigrants to the west Muslims including and you can see now like in in UK Britain you have second third generation immigrants [1:15:28] Muslims already especially from Pakistan. Uh they sort of they absorbed into the the mainstream culture. Those who hold on to their religious beliefs and who have become radicalized. The word is radicalized. It happens. But they are very much fewer in number. But as you said, you only need 10%. [1:15:50] Yeah. To be you know to be off the rails and it can derail the entire train. So uh but they are small number the the majority uh sort of get assimilated and they get lost into the overall the larger culture community they forget their roots so they become British people or they become Americanized and things like that. [1:16:14] Uh but more importantly uh why the west is so attractive is that it allows you to be what you want to be. you know, you have the freedoms. That's it. That's what people are looking for. [1:16:26] And anybody Muslims or whoever who goes to the west, they go like, you know, I I'd like I just I can do whatever I want to do and I'm not bothered with my neighbors. My neighbors are not bothered with me. You see, which is so meaning that this is this is the natural state of human beings [1:16:44] of even of Muslims. So the things that makes them misbehave or exhibit behaviors that seem disjointed are the result of agenda making from by others. Someone you know pokes them and uh you know use manipulates the situation and makes them do this and do that but in their natural state they're just normal people. So if you want to help the the Islamic countries we have to help control this agenda setting. you know those groups that come with their own agendas and try to curb their influence and for for that we need discourse we need open discussion free speech which is another product that is [1:17:27] kind of absent among in Muslim countries you know including ours that's there that's a big big problem here when you don't have as much free discussion free speech then uh [1:17:39] even the ability to question norms right is is kind of like prohibited yeah I mean you cannot question this, you cannot question that. That in itself is dangerous. So, uh the the one and only step in the battle to overcome this is just allow people to talk. That's it. The moments people can discuss openly and they can question. You find that these people who set the agendas, they lose their grip. They can lose their grip very fast. There's a huge reason for that. You know if I can deliver my famous lecture on uh scientific truth and religious truth. [1:18:15] Sure. Sure. Sure. You would agree? Because because you see real life depends on real things, tangible things. You must do real things like you know the studio works building stands. It's all based on science, engineering, mathematics, real stuff. Uh those are called scientific truths, right? Uh scientific truth uh they are truth because they really work. All right. Uh you it's very difficult to deny a scientific truth. Okay. Uh if the water boils at 100° Celsius, it boils 100°C. You're not going to be able to drink it 100° CC. You know, no matter how many prayers you you say, it's not going to [1:18:54] happen. But then you have religious truth. Religious truth, you know, uh to be a safe side, let me use a Christian example. Uh like Jesus Christ, Jesus Christ walked on water. It's a religious truth. You have to accept it. If you don't accept that Jesus Christ walked on water, you it's bit difficult to be a Christian. Although now 21st century, some Christians may try to find means to explain that if Jesus Christ didn't uh raise the deaduh. It's difficult to be a Christian because this is what you got to believe and Jesus Christ is son of God. You have to believe all this. So [1:19:30] these are religious truths which don't have a scientific basis. There's no way you're going to you and I are going to walk on water or change water into wine, you know. Uh so but but those are religious truths. Every religion has got religious truth. It's called faith. You take it or you leave it. If you don't accept it, then you can't belong to that religion. But here's where the the the bridge doesn't meet the [1:19:57] the rubber meet with the road the edge of the of the river. It doesn't cross the full river is right. You cannot use religious truths which are a lot of it is non-scientific illogical to solve real real world problems which run on scientific truths. This this is a big problem in a lot of societies that still rely on religion. This is the huge problem in the Middle East where religious truths hold a lot of sway big influence on society trying to solve issues which you need scientific truths to solve them. You cannot use religious truth to solve real world problems or or not to a great [1:20:41] amount of success. Religious truths are good for spirituality you know thinking about well you know other worldly things and hereafter things like that that I mean that's how religions evolve but they run on religious truths which are not scientific truth Jesus Christ could walk on water according to Christianity you we cannot [1:21:03] I saw tiger tiger woods walk on water in winter in winter on on Nike Nike commercial So you can't go design some system in your country with your people in a real world situation based on something to do with the fact that or the belief that Jesus walked on water. It's not going to work or Jesus converted water into into wine. So this is where the Islamic countries for example they have things which they want to do based on faith. uh but uh the the logical explanations the scientific basis can be debate debated highly debatable uh bottom line is uh [1:21:48] religious truth cannot be debated it uh it no of course if you if you want to be a member of that religion you you cannot debate it otherwise you're not you don't belong to that religion it's as simple as that is faith either you take it or you leave it if you if you take it you belong you belong if you if you leave it you're a disbeliever It's as simple as that. But to try to connect that to real life, to real world, tangible world, that's where the problem starts. Because in science, you know, you you you can debate if if you come up with a new phone, you know, that can you [1:22:24] press a button and a cop of latte comes out at the end. So I can debate. I said, "No, are you trying to call me? Is it show me how it works?" You know, then you have to show it. You have to show how it works and we have to question debate and then if it if it works I'm not going to blow myself up [1:22:42] or blow you up. Yeah. Or if it doesn't work I'm not going to blow you up either. Yeah. We just do something else. I think this is very pro very interesting for you as a non-Muslim. Right. [1:22:54] As a non-faith non-religious guy. I just look I mean I read most of the I I I did my early reading and I just decided it wasn't for me. Do you know what I mean? Um cuz I just even at 9 years old I could see the the flaws in the system. Let's just not say which books I read but I suffice to say I read most of them. Right. And [1:23:13] yeah. So I know I mean three of us are old enough to remember those days when this kind of discussion in even on the coffee shop we were scared. Remember those days right? Hey don't talk like that. You're crazy. Can they come and get you? Remember those days? [1:23:28] No I think I think I think now it's even worse. No, but you you've got this this is incredible. You see how we couch our discussion, right? We are very careful. This is ironic because we are we are trying to play on the fact that most people don't understand what we're saying because of the language that we're using. But we want actually people to be more intelligent than they are because then they will see the the things that they've been lied to. That's the irony here. [1:23:51] Yeah. Here here goes. Right. I think um the what what site points out in the in the Middle East is there's already a shift in terms of um in terms of the ideology let's call it an the ideology of governing right going from uh a theocratic base which is religious based to more secular based and scientific based [1:24:18] scientific right to what works Yes, I think they're coming to realization. Correct. I like his analogy of religious truth and scientific truth. Uh you know I I think that's that's a very good way of [1:24:33] I think people will not give up on religion because people do find religion uh there is religion serves a purpose for a lot of people. So uh I don't think they're going to give up on religion. uh but what they have to uh switch their focus is that uh when you're talking about building a society, moving a country forward, building an economy, development, things like that, you have to be realistic, practical, logical, scientific. So that may entail separating the two. You keep religion in your heart. Religion belongs in the heart. You keep the religion in your [1:25:10] heart. Your faith, your practice, your beliefs, you keep it there. And uh to solve all your other problems, real world issues, you have to be logical, you have to be rational, you have to be scientific. Uh that is the only thing that works [1:25:24] especially now with 21st century everything is so advanced. The latest gizmo is artificial intelligence which we are just starting you know we're just starting to crawl and the the possibilities seem [1:25:38] incredible. So I I don't want to blow I don't want to blow sunshine up Uncle Sam's ass, right? But um you know in America, right, um pretty much most of what is decided in America is is done on their holy book. You know what I mean? Right. And Christianity plays a big part in America's um um [1:25:57] What do you mean done on their book? I mean it's you know uh the Bible I mean even even the president has to show an avowed interest in their religion, right? True or not? True or not? False or not? No. I I would say I would say the difference is this. Well, I would say that America has been able to enrich itself so well from an economic standpoint even with this [1:26:19] well there's a very this ideology difference when you look at how the American I just want to say because like faith exists everywhere right to what extent and where do you keep it do you know what I mean right I know but if you look at why I I I'm I'm I've been studying the the US cultural society quite closely because of my interest. [1:26:41] Actually, you are in fact American, right, sir? No, I'm No, no. I mean, but the the the the institution when it was already formed um they already foresee this the the the founding fathers foraw it. I mean the where they where they intentionally have separation of religion and state where they have check and balances within their inst. So they institutionalize a system of governance right that in spite of it being the society may have a religious ban to a certain proportion it does not uh it does not basically um uh undermine the institution but make it function right and and grow and and [1:27:31] develop that's what I'm suggesting here they've managed to compartmentalize both collectively see this is not let one hijack the Let's take about let's so what what I'm I was trying to imply to to to say and I wanted his his his thought on this right Islam and the Muslim uh theocratic religion has gone a lot is a long way already in the Middle East and gone through a few permutation and evolution right and we are seeing today the differences between Saudi the GCC countries and all the tribal issues that you still mention that are very much being powered by uh [1:28:15] uh uh religious inspired dogma, okay? In order to control the population and carry out their consolidation of power and and fermenting whatever the violence that is still ongoing. Whereas when you look at those that have evolved right and the latest to me being uh Saudi right and in a very drastic way which is to do exactly that which is to use scientific truth and put the religious truth at the back burner [1:28:49] in the heart leave that in the heart you know the problem lies where the violence in the Middle East is where it is still uh a tool for the for those who wants to have power. [1:29:02] It's agenda setting. Yeah, exactly. The politicians, the authoritarian people, the monarchs, monarchies, everybody has got an agenda. So, I mean, if I look at the last three to four decades of of Malaysia, right? It's actually agenda setting. is a gender setting of uh of of of uh of the the the how we educate our majority society and all that. So the Middle East I think is going to get ahead of even us looking at where they are going. I've I mean the last I was down in Abu Dhabi for example, right? My I mean the people there uh in terms of religiosity uh or the outward appearance of it right [1:29:54] in their daily life is so much different than what is happening within our side of the region whether it's Malaysia or Indonesia. Singapore on the other hand, I was just back from Singapore last night, you know. Uh the maritime lawyer, one of their best is uh is a Malay, you know. Um [1:30:14] Malaysian Malay. No, no. Uh Singaporean. Okay. Right. And so we know very well. So where do you think the Muslim world is heading, my friend? Maybe we should wrap up on because uh short of time, right? [1:30:27] Yeah. Uh on the Abrahamic uh accord. Sure. uh agree or not, like it or not, it's going to happen, right? And it's going to uh create major change in the Middle East. We were talking earlier from 1948, formation of Israel until 50,6070s, Cam David Accord 78, peace treaty between Egypt and Israel and then going to the Arab Spring. That was a phase where the risk profile changed in the Middle East. uh the threat profile in the 1940s, you know, you had the the after 1940s, after Second World War, third world countries became independent. Colonialism uh receded, you know, took well the the [1:31:12] the British and the French withdrew. They were more independent countries in throughout the world, especially in Africa, Middle East. They were left on their own. They had to rule, govern themselves on their own. But the the colonials especially the British left behind solid infrastructure systems, administrative systems, education systems, health systems, land survey. The British were quite good at [1:31:37] uh roads. So that carried them by itself. It had its own momentum. They just had to manage it and things went very well. And one of the beneficiaries is our country, our region, Singapore, Malaysia. We benefited a lot from that. But unfortunately in the Middle East people started experimenting because they were not I I put it down to skill sets. They didn't know there was no leewanu there. They didn't have skill sets to go to the next level. Uh but they had to answer to their people every day. So they started experimenting to keep the people's support. So some went [1:32:14] into authoritarian systems, military dictatorships, some turned to religion. But the the military dictatorships held sway for a for for a long time. Egypt has basically military until today. started with Gamal Nasir and then uh Sadat these were all military people and then uh that uh was the guy who replaced Sadat who died [1:32:38] uh CC no before Morsi the the air force pilot Hosni Mubarak Mubarak what was general in the air force yeah he he was the one who signed was it he the one who signed the treaty with Israel [1:32:51] uh that was Saddat Sat and then Mosi took over for a couple of years or less than two years and now replaced by C general. Uh Syria has been army throughout and so it's been army dictatorship and then the the the Islamist came in influential. You find that Saudi Arabia the Wahhabis and Salafies had a very strong influence. You find that in uh Tunisia the the the Muslim Brotherhood in Egypt there's a strong influence of religion. uh but basically it has been authoritarian but the the the the threat profile at that time they use the new state of Israel as the big boogeyman you the Israelis going [1:33:34] to take over all of all our countries greater Israel is going to expand until Saudi Arabia and everything all these maps started coming out you know Israel was a boogeyman uh which helped this authoritarian regime stay in power then the risk profile changed They had they faced more threats from inside the the Islamic agenda. The Islamist the jihadist started you know fighting back pushing back and toppling governments. So Israel now uh since 1948 about what 70 over years they have proven that no we are staying put we only want this is what we want and they have given up they [1:34:16] did give up they gave the Sinai back to Egypt camp David they gave Gaza to uh the Palestinians and the West Bank uh so they just said no we just want to stay within this this area and the Golan Heights there's an offer on the table if if Syria signs a peace treaty with Israel I think they will return the Golan Heights maybe now not now it's going to be very difficult but uh uh they have always been able to trade away the land for peace so they just want to stay in their place the Arab countries or substantial number of them realize this now Israel is not a threat to them [1:34:49] which is why now Saudi Arabia is so friendly to Israel and you have the Abrahamic accords now Morocco has signed on UAE has signed on and uh they're expecting Syria this new guy to sign on with Israel but now there's some fighting going on uh but the big catch will be Saudi Arabia and Saudi Arabia is really inclined towards uh you can see it establishing relationships with Israel which is why one theory says October 7th [1:35:16] happened because of that to derail the Abrahamic Accords the Abrahamic Accords uh because okay it was moved by uh Trump's son-in-law Jared Kushner when Trump Trump Trump won Trump Trump won Trump Trump 1.0 moved Abraimic Accords through Jared Kushner, but he was able to move it because there's already an undercurrent among Arab countries. Some Arab countries once they already it's time to make peace with Israel because now the risk profile has changed. The threat profiles have changed in the Middle East. Israel is not a threat militarily to any Arab country. They [1:35:54] have as they have proven it. If they wanted to, they could have invaded uh Egypt and kept Sinai, you know, and just say forget about it. They can do it you know probably overnight which they did now in the Golan Heights because of the chaos in Syria. Israel has moved troops into completely taken over the Golan Heights now because they are saying that we do not know what's going to happen in in Syria. And it's true because this guy the new president or ruler of Syria Golani he only controls less than 40% way only Damascus Damascus and surrounding areas. Outside of that you [1:36:25] have other groups the Kurds u so many groups are in Syria. So the Israelis are worried. So because of that they move their troops into into the Golan area now completely taken over but I think if they can have a peace treaty they will give that up too because they have no intention of invading other lands. They want to stay put and build their own country. The Arabs seem to accept that now. The Arabs are realizing that yeah the Jews just want to have their holy land and they want to stay there and they we don't have they're not a military threat. They're not uh imminent [1:36:57] or exist existential threat to us but their own the the threats in their own country are uh increasing. You find various Islamic groups, jihadi groups, uh political opponents organiz or organizing themselves and exerting more pressure on the ruling regimes. And these people are not democratic. There's no democracy. This is the problem. This is the biggest problem in the Middle East. There's no democracy. So if I lose my perch, I lose my head. You see? So that's why now they feel that it's time to make friends with Israel. That is the push that is coming from the Arabs. That [1:37:33] is where the Abrahamic Accords are coming from that which is why they are happening. How revolutionary do you feel or do you think the Abrahamic Accords has been [1:37:45] ultimately it will have to me it'll have a huge impact on the psychology of the Arab street. the general masses because for the last 70 years, you know, the Jews are the enemy. You know, they are the the wicked people who have taken our land. Suddenly, you're going to have a Jewish ambassador in your country. You're going to have your ambassador open up your embassy in Israel. There's going to be travel and uh Israel without a doubt, it is a very developed uh economy, very advanced economy. they have much to offer in terms of uh products. Uh they they have they buy a [1:38:23] lot of things you know they will import a lot of things because they they make things. So the Middle East will be a source of resources for Israel. A lot of things will go from Middle East into Israel. That means trade, that means money and people will realize that. So it is going to create a psychological impact on the Arabs because these people who have been enemies now for what 70 over years suddenly now they are friends. So that will change the way people think and uh this is where I I foresee the boogie man is disappearing will disappear once you you make peace [1:39:01] with Israel in Abrahamic accords. you cannot be beating the uh the war drum against Israel in the in the local market and bazaar anymore. So that will make people think like uh you know okay so we don't have any more enemies. Israel is no more an enemy. Uh so they may decide to focus their attention against other things you know like then what's what's so problem? what's a what's what's making our lives uh challenging or difficult or why can't we have more change if we can recognize Israel and make peace with Israel why can't we have other changes in our society you know move forward so they [1:39:42] will start thinking about democracy and the freedom of to speak and things like that so there's going to be change in the Middle East but the the immediate the immediate the immediate urgent requirement now is for the Middle East regimes to safeguard their own perch and they see that in making friends with uh with Israel and especially now the Americans have generally been withdrawing from the Middle East. They don't want to engage and Trump is a good example. He doesn't want to spend money. He doesn't want to engage so much. So you find that over time the US security umbrella thing [1:40:19] might recede which he already has. They pul they pulled out from Afghanistan. They pulled out from uh Iraq. So uh if that happens then who's going to who's going to manage the uh the security umbrella? Who's going to provide the security cover in the Middle East? So this is where the Israelis may step in one way or you just create peace, [1:40:41] make peace with everybody. You don't need security umbrella. I I can see um the GCC uh the Emirates um and and Saudi having a solution at least MBS is trying which is to diversify the economy um and actually using the oil wealth to to try and create other industry so that their people can be um can be well off. I think that's the only solution for any country if you ask me. I mean that's the story of uh uh China's stability internally you know so that's a challenge for them being such a big big country and that's a challenge also for all the other Muslim countries so to [1:41:24] speak you know like ourselves and Indonesia yeah so yeah I agree with you yeah I mean regardless of color or stripe all human beings want the same thing right all the things that you talked about earlier say exactly um you know just the ability to put food on the you know, take care of your family and to have a peaceful life and have, you know, some some people that you love and trust. Do you know what I mean? That's that's all we want, right? [1:41:47] That's right. Um, I think I speak on behalf of Sam to say that um site you're one of the very very few people in Malaysia that are able to um weave a very compelling and very truthful uh nar narrative between geopolitics, between faith and the human condition. and you've given us a real perspective into what's happening in the Middle East so that people can better understand it and then make better decisions for themselves because at the end of the day people need to have that truth in front of them to be I think more uh well-rounded human beings and to make better decisions for our family. I [1:42:22] think also I speak on behalf of Sam to say that you know we're the early we're in the early you know stages of the Gutshot podcast but I can easily see how you will be a regular fixture to talk about not just the Middle East and what's happening around there but also Malaysia and I think you know perspective [1:42:39] yeah he he has uh on the economic perspective we haven't touched we haven't even touched that side so I can see how we're going to have many very colorful discussions in the future yeah Sam yeah I want to thank site I think It's been a great discussion. I really enjoyed this, you know. Thanks again, brother, for coming on. [1:42:58] Yes, man. And you know, my first time I'm meeting you in person in the flesh after having read your blog for so many years. You've lived up. You know, people say you shouldn't meet your heroes, right? I think in this case, it's fully justified. There's been no there's been no disappointment whatsoever. In fact, you've surpassed all expectations. So, thank you S. You're our first guest and you will definitely not be the last time on this podcast. I can show you. [1:43:22] Thank you very much. Okay. Cheers. Thank you. That's good. All right. Cool. Well, I love that conversation. All this.