# Political Parties Breaking Up and Its a Good Thing. (Episode 54) Published: 2026-03-05T02:41:13+00:00 ## Summary Sam Saad and Syed Akbar Ali argue that the ongoing splintering of major Malaysian political parties is a vital and overdue cleansing process rather than a disaster. With no single coalition commanding absolute power, politicians are facing unprecedented legal and electoral accountability for patronage abuse. As systemic leakages consume roughly a quarter of the national budget, they assert that political turnover and private sector resilience, rather than increased taxation, are key to national progress. ## Key Takeaways - [1:37] Frequent transitions of power since 2018 have turned Malaysian politics into a hazardous career where past misgovernance and patronage abuse are routinely prosecuted. - [2:42] The practice of political appointees occupying lucrative board seats on GLCs remains an abusive patronage mechanism that distracts from core statutory governance. - [19:09] Electoral turnovers act as a necessary house cleaning, establishing a precedent that criminal corruption and abuses of power carry no statutory expiry date. - [25:24] Shifting ruling coalitions disrupt entrenched ecosystems of state contracts, licenses, and monopolies, forcing crony-linked corporations to face sudden legal and financial exposure. - [37:43] Senior civil servants face career marginalisation during regime changes if they compromise their professional neutrality to serve the partisan interests of the incumbent government. - [48:23] Eliminating corrupt procurement leakages and white elephant projects could save 20 to 25 percent of the national budget, completely avoiding the need for expanded taxation. - [58:26] Malaysia's underlying economic resilience is generated primarily by the private sector and civil service continuity rather than the political leadership. ## Chapters 0:00 The Ultimate Shake-Up: Why Political Chaos is Actually a Good Thing 4:30 The Most Hazardous Job in Malaysia: Why Politicians Are Finally Sweating 9:15 The DAP Ultimatum & The Disgusting Truth About GLC Appointments 14:00 House Cleaning: How Changing Governments Put Corrupt Patrons Behind Bars 20:45 The Civil Service Trap: Navigating the Danger Zone of Shifting Coalitions 26:20 The 25% Leakage: Why We Don't Need New Taxes (If We Stop the Rot) 32:10 The Private Sector Rebellion: Why Our Economy Will Thrive Without Them ## Transcript [0:00] Welcome to the Gutshot podcast. I'm Shamsul Sam. Uh back with me after Chinese New Year is uh my friend and partner say Akwa. Good morning and happy new year. [0:12] Well, ladies and gentlemen, today we're going to have a very hot conversation I think right. looking at actually the breaking up of all these political parties, right? We see that uh PKR has broken up. We see um uh what do you call even in AMNO breaking up and we also see um DAP uh making moves to uh pull out of the government if they are they if their conditions are not met you know funnily enough also just recently I think yesterday I believe the MP for Kota Malaka issued an ultimatum of you know either he goes or we go. So setting that up, you know, we're going to have some [1:04] real thinking to do and this is a podcast to build a thinking movement. Therefore, please spread to your uh friends, colleagues, family member and build this community, subscribe to our channel so that we can build up a thinking movement of citizens. Say let's get to this. I want to throw this to you first. With all that is going on, um I think politics has become a very hazardous occupation. [1:37] Shall you start please? Yeah. Okay. Uh yeah, a lot of things are happening and then uh I I like to explain why uh politics has now become the most hazardous profession in Malaysia. Other countries also go through upheavalss, you know, parties break up and things like that, but it's not so hazardous. In Malaysia, it's very hazardous. And I think we we'll we'll share some thoughts on this. The person you mentioned is the the DAP's uh member of parliament. Yeah. [2:06] And he said either he goes or we go. He was referring to the the the the present controversy over the the MC the commissioner and all that. I no names but uh that he was referring to that is is actually actually an ultimatum. What [2:24] I think the MP is what is interesting is his statement was about two days ago. Oh he was two days ago member of parliament. Okay. Uh and then uh last week I think yeah last week there was another issue where the segen secretary general of the DAP Mr. Anthony Lok [2:42] he made a statement which I thought was well kind of interesting. He said that uh the DAP will reassess their position. Yeah. Uh sometime in July July this year whether they their people should be remain as in the GLC's you know in the boards of directors of GLC's and other government positions and something like that which I thought was kind of strange. Uh why wait so long to assess your position? [3:12] 5 months. uh what in the first place why make this kind of statement? What's going on? I mean is there some problem inside the uh you know the government or DAP feels uncomfortable uh having their people their nominees sit in the boards of GLC's and things like that. Normally you know the in the GLC system uh we have had political appointees or people who are you know considered friendly parties you know appointed to the GLC's for a long time. our practice for decades. Uh so suddenly for Anthony Lo to make this kind of a statement uh what's really going onh so I uh I read it as unhappiness [3:54] within this uh within the the the the political parties within the coalition and the statement by the YB Kamlaka giving a sort of ultimatum it's either him or ush uh that is further proof that all is not well uh in the ruling coalition Pakatan Harapan about two weeks ago. It was a turn of uh party basu in Prikata National Party has broken up you know. Yeah. uh the many of their quite a few of their uh what divisional heads and also those who are members of parliament including their deputy president Hamza Zodin have been kicked out from so there's a bit of turmoil going on in [4:45] Batu which ultimately will affect Prikata National the coalition to which they belong to and of course Prikata Prikata National PN the anchor so to speak is past. So past is past is now they are kind of stable. They've always been stable you know no major controversies in past but uh we have to see uh what's going to happen. So uh the the parties themselves are unstable now. All right. Uh it's not just the politics that has become unstable. The parties themselves are unstable. The major parties. Uh okay. Why has politics become the most hazardous profession? because since uh uh 208 [5:28] the political landscape has really shifted in this country and I think these political parties are still uh trying to get to grips with what is really going on on the ground. You know you see they have two there are two uh two things going on. One is the the the political landscape, the politics in the country, how the parties perform in the elections. Uh they're performing badly since 208 as and 2018 and especially 2022. They're all performing badly. You know, no one won simple majority in the last general elections 2022. Uh so none of them are really popular with the electorate. So that is [6:10] a reality. But many of them don't seem to understand this. Why? Or maybe they understand it but they think they can overcome it by forming these strange coalitions, you know, because why? Because I think they are they right now their main priority is survival and self-preservation. So it's a bit too late to go and ask the people why don't you like us? Because the elections keep coming. So it's simply like with whom can we form a coalition so that we can still survive and be relevant? That's what's going on. [6:45] Can I say one thing though just to interject that um I think it's more about how do I survive rather than their interest of why don't you like us? They are more inclined to say like us regardless. You know here we give you the uh the the formula of three R. I give you the formula of Malay unity you know like us and they are finding that actually this particular formulas are not working for people who are voting [7:22] they just refuse to ask the people what can I do for you yeah this seems to be uh yeah they just are allergic to this they just cannot go down to the ground and ask people why are you unhappy and what can we do for you you know I'm your elected representative let me do something for you. No, as you say, they want to tell us. [7:44] This is what I think is the best for you. Uh because this is also helps me survive. Yes. Helps my party survive. But you see, let's go back to the issue now. 208, you know, the BN lost 2/3s majority, which was a bad bad omen at the time. 5 years later, they lost actually more seats in parliament. And uh 10 years later, 2018, they were kicked out. All right. Uh throughout this process, they never bothered to stop and do a postmotive and find out why we lost. Not not that I know of, not that we know of. And then uh 2018, they lost power. For the first time in the history of independent Malaysia [8:24] uh well actually yeah 63 years since independence. So for the first time there was a change in leadership. There was a transition power transition which was handled extremely very well by the Malaysian public. There were no issues despite the first time changing government in 63 years there was no issues. Meaning that the people have matured significantly. You know in other countries even re-elections there are riots there in Indonesia there are protests you know they burn down buses and things like that. Okay. 2018 they lost power. the next general election 2022 they all [9:02] lost. No single party won. Uh no one won a simple majority. So at the end of the day uh the the the Aong had to step in to do his uh his constitutional uh responsibility basically to uh put a government in place and so we have the present government. So [9:21] um they all perform badly. Then the following year 2023 they we had elections in the six states. Again the ruling coalition performed very badly, very poorly you know and the latest is the Saba state elections which is uh a few months back December I think and again the ruling coalition performed very badly and DAP lost 80 all their seats. So so what does this mean? [9:48] It means that you are not assured anymore. If you're a political party, you're not assured of this continuously ruling the country or continuously ruling the state which we had under Barisa National from 1957 to 19 uh uh until 2018 where Dr. Mahadi could be prime minister for 22 years. Najib was prime minister for 9 years. All that is history. It's not going to happen. uh politics is now a very very uncertain uncertain profession. If you want to opt for politics as a career uh you need to have a very your your horizon has is very limited. Okay. Why is it hazardous? Hazardous because [10:31] unfortunately in this country our politics is very closely tied with political patronage. the the axis between business and politics has been going on for a long time and ultimately these kind of things lead to behavior that is less than good which involves politicians. So if your party keeps winning the elections from 1957 to 208 that you know 63 years maybe that's okay because uh even if you did something that is less than good uh it'll probably never come to light or uh you know so much time has now just get swept under the cupboard [11:12] that's it you know water under the bridge you see but now with the with the parties losing power and new governments taking over. So the the the new government that takes over uh without a doubt they will go and dig up all the not nice things about the people who are in previously in power and you can call it vendetta you can call it trying to set things right uh you know following the uh the law by the book which I don't disagree with if wrong has been done then it has to be exposed and if someone has to be punished it has to be they have to be punished. So we find that [11:55] since the uh BN lost power in 2018, there have been some major uh prosecutions and convictions in the courts in Malaysia. Uh of course the most famous one is a former prime minister Najib Raza. [12:14] He was uh charged in court with corruption and he has been jailed. Yeah. He was jailed for the first conviction. I think he was jailed for I think we have to be very honest. If he had not lost the election, I don't think the uh the the YNDB scandal would have prosecuted uh would have caused anybody to be prosecuted. [12:35] Well, to be factually correct, there was an attorney general appointed by him who said that he had done no wrong. Yeah. The one MDB case, I don't want to mention names. I can't remember his name anyway, but there was a AG who said that, you know. So, so, so, uh, he first received uh, I think 12 years and then he was pardoned and he was reduced to like 6 years or something and then most recently in December last year, the other charges which he was charged with relating to 1 MDB again the case came to a conclusion and he has been jailed for a further 15-year term. [13:10] So say let's get back to where we are at right now in terms of uh what do you call the I mean the repercussion of losing power and the the uh and and whatever uh alleged um mis uh uh misgovernance or you know wrongdoings that you may uh incur during your time when you hold position. conditions are coming back to bite you, you know, and it bites you hard. Um, and that's basically extremely hazardous, right? [13:51] Yeah. Yeah. Hey, the other thing that actually I think I want to point out when you were talking just now that it struck to me and I want our audience to think about this. Why did DAP when DAP mentioned the DAP president mentioned that they have to rethink about their position in government and GLC positions. I actually stopped in my tracks when he mentioned GLC positions. You know number one you and I are people who are always against the formations of GLC's. Number two, we always say they are either monopolies or actually ineffective. Number three, I don't understand why [14:41] political appointees should be in GLC's. It becomes just a place for them to to actually get good uh monetary and cushy cushy benefits. So to me, the fact that he admitted that they got their people in GLC positions is actually pretty insulting and disgusting to me. You should never be as a political appointee even accept GLC position. It's none of your business. You stick to statutory governance. So that uh I want our audience to think. All right. Who are they working for? So go back to you Mr. S. [15:29] Yeah. So uh let me finish this short list of uh uh politicians who are facing various um you know issues through the legal system. So we already spoke about Najib. The most recent is uh because this is a case already convicted in the court. Tantri Mohamad Isa [15:49] uh he was a former cabinet minister and all that. Uh so he has been jailed for 6 years on a corruption charge and uh this was just uh recently so he started his six-year jail term. Uh bear in mind that uh the the charges of which he was accused they took place years ago years a quite some years ago you know it's not recent. Uh and then uh you had one more guy, the former deputy prime minister. He was charged on 47 counts of corruption, but uh the charges were DNA discharge not amounting to equitital. [16:25] Oh, we've got plenty of that these days. So uh so uh that is uh well he was he was charged. He was actually prosecuted in the court. Right. And then uh you have another cabinet minister who once who was once a member of parliament for jaya. He was found guilty of a charge of 2 million corruption and I think he was given a jail sentence and a fine but uh I think it is in the appeals process. So it is still in the appeals process but the point is he has been charged in court. Now all these things happened after 2018 after Amnu Barisan National lost the election sir and then uh you also [17:05] have the case this is interesting of a former DAP chief minister no names who has been charged who has been facing corruption charges uh uh in court and I think his case is still um in the process and now the latest is uh there's talk that uh they want to investigate a former uh a son of a former prime minister going back all the way to 2004 I think regarding a project that he was involved in uh where there is suspected of uh you know impropri improprieties and things like that so that there there is talk that they're going to investigate uh this case also so the [17:49] point I'm trying to say is that this is why politics is hazardous because over the years because of the political patronage system and the entrenched uh uh the uh all these people being entrenched in politics in business and the and the axis that connects them both for years for decades you know they've been doing things the wrong way these cases are um straightforward um corrupt behavior right there also other cases where which may not be so black and white uh but where there still could be abuse of power things like that which is what now they're investigating [18:34] like the case going back to 2004. So once the the power changes there's a transition of power from one political coalition to another coalition the succeeding coalition goes back and digs up all the cases from the past and prosecutes them. That's what is happening now. So this is why politics is really hazardous in Malaysia. Now I think this this uh some may call it a witch hunt or a vendetta or whatever. I disagree. I agree with what is happening because if someone has done wrong, go ahead and get them. [19:09] Yeah. And because there is there are no statutory limits on crime, right? If you commit a crime forever, you know, you you're legally liable. uh you know so if they have committed a crime whether it takes 20 years or 30 years or forever go ahead because this will be a lesson to future wannabe politicians. [19:32] I mean say it you must you must bear in mind that whatever you do today if you do it wrong is going to come back and bite you. The words that you used just now be 10 years down the road 20 years down the road it'll come back and bite you. In fact, as Rayad, as citizens, we wanted it to bite you and cut you in half. Okay? I mean, if you think about it, right? Um the problem with our what do you call fourth or fifth estate as uh as the journalism uh uh profession is called is very timid in Malaysia because of the licensing and publishing act or something like that, [20:14] right? Cuz in order for you to be a publisher, you have to have a license from the government. So if you get something wrong, your license may not get if you not get something wrong. If they don't like what you're saying, you know, um you don't you don't get to but they may yank your license. But Bloomberg doesn't have to worry about that. And I let me put it this way. Uh from my uh personal business experience, Bloomberg is very thorough in terms of when they make a report. All right. So when they make a report, there are two cases that they have actually brought [20:53] up. Okay. One uh is obviously about corruption. Second is uh the one that they made a report on actually the syndic syndicates involved in actually uh bringing um bringing workers into Malaysia. That's Bloomberg's report. All right. Now the question is very simple. I as somebody who understands business I say to the people who are actually mentioned by Bloomberg is they should take if they don't agree or they think they are innocent the lawsuit should be either in New York or actually uh in the because that is where their original uh publications are right so um [21:46] this all has to be invested investigated properly. That is all um we as citizens need to be able to see because why um President Nixon was was kicked out of office because of the Washington Post reporting that actually caused um I know at least two members of his senior administration was go went to jail. the Nixon administration remember when Nixon had to resign and he was fortunately pardoned by Ford otherwise he would go to jail as well right so let's be a not let's not be a banana republic the government uh and its enforcement agency have a duty to actually provide a fair and [22:44] balanced uh investigation on all such cases that is all citizens should demand for you know so when you talk about hazardous uh politics right and you talk about effects on patronage these are effects on patronage that makes it both hazardous for the patrons and the protag okay and the people who are dependent on this patroniz system. [23:20] Exactly. So, so this uh the change in uh in governments or rather the political parties losing elections or them being not able to form a simple government. They they have been forced into marrying different partners in strange coalitions. All this now has got a significant impact on the uh the the political patronage system, the entire ecosystem. Uh there's a lot of a lot of topsyturvy going on. uh the the the frequent government changes they um disrupt so many things like who's going to be in the uh board member of the GLC's who shall be the CEOs of the GLC's [24:09] uh you know uh because ultimately all these people have to be appointed and of course they will be appointed by the whichever coalition is in power at that time and of course uh the coalitions or the political leadership will want to appoint um user friendly uh people I like your word user friendly [24:32] user user friendly people to these kind of positions uh in government uh linked companies government agencies and things like that I mean it it goes without saying it's it's it's it's common sense [24:46] yes but but it does uh so what happens to the previous uh people who were appointed to the boards or CEOs or what happens to uh businesses and corporations who you know Malaysia is a land of licenses, contracts, monopolies, franchises and you know that kind of thing. So what happens to corporations and businesses who had close links with uh uh government in order to survive in their business who were given licenses, contracts and franchises and all that by the previous government. uh and the previous government was is now in the opposition you know so what happens to [25:24] them now so of course there's a lot of reshuffleling and realignment and rejigging the whole uh whole uh ecosystem going on uh there will be people who will basically get replaced there will be companies who were given franchises before may they may not be able to renew their franchises now or they have to switch their allegiances and things like that meaning they have to seek new political patronage because the the the underlying weakness here. The bad thing is the political patronage system. Uh so that is what is has made uh uh politics and everything else so [26:03] hazardous because it is closely linked with the money and business and if there is any kind of as I said misbehavior you know wrong behavior where money and business is involved most likely somebody will end up going to court so that's what is happening now all right so um you know the Malay proverb Kaliba scalibai. [26:30] Each time there's a major spring tide, high tide, it can change the coastline. This is what is happening now. So all the the float sam the what do you call those driftwood? Is it driftwood? Huh? All the garbage, the driftwood, the pieces of wood. [26:45] There's so many garbage and driftwood in it. All that will be all that will be swept out, you know, and maybe the new ones will come in cuz that's what that's what is happening now. So this is this may not happen in other countries. Other countries also have massive political changes. Italy is one, Japan is another, you know, where they have constant changes in in coalition governments and the the prime minister changes like once every other year or something which is becoming frequent now in Europe also in UK especially Netherlands. [27:15] But you don't find that people going to jail every time there's a change in the prime minister or change in the political leadership of the country because over there maybe they keep their noses a bit more clean, you know. So therefore the new government that comes in does not have to take a broom and a or a which [27:31] no they don't have to take a pony a firing squad to come up and go after the previous guys who have done all the wrong things because there they do things they're more transparent you know they're not as maybe not as corrupted less naughty behavior so they're okay but in Malaysia no and this is a new phenomenon in Malaysia this only started 8 years ago [27:50] say after the Barisa national lost their power I said would Would you agree with me if I were to say? I just want to finish that point. Sure. I So, so for those young people who are planning a career in politics, you really must do your mathematics and arithmetic very carefully because uh winning a seat in parliament does not mean that you ride off into the sunset and you know everything is hunky dory fine. Uh if you're not careful after you after the next election you you might end up in court. not only answering for yourself, maybe answering for someone else's uh mistakes [28:28] of which you are part knowingly or unknowingly. So better be careful. You you know what I was going to say is actually I don't think this is a bad thing at all. It's very good. It's a house cleaning process. In fact, um, if I were I was I was comparing it to the other countries like like you mentioned to me like what's happening with the Dutch parliament, what's happening in Japan, what's happening in Korea, you know, um, this relatively constant changes of government even in UK and in New Zealand or even Australia. But the difference as you rightly put there was not a big element of uh uh of [29:12] of of uh misconduct. I I wouldn't call it wan. You know why I wouldn't call it wan is because if you've done something wrong I will hunt you. Yeah. Exactly. Yeah. That's my point. I think I think part of the problem in Malaysia is because over the last four decades people have gone into politics not for national service. People has gone into politics for power and actually for wealth you know [29:40] wealth. Yeah. Uh and and therefore this is the phenomena that we are facing. If you were to ask me okay the biggest bane uh for Malaysia has been corruption. Number one to me the number one failure of Malaysia is systemic and political elite corruption. [30:02] The political patronage system. Yes. So um that probably half our uh probably half our GDP. I brani say I would say that our GDP would have been double without the corruption that has been going on over the last 40 50 decades. [30:22] Yes. Sorry. Uh five decades. Yeah. So if you look at it from that point of view, okay, I I want to see this constant changes until we get people who will not go into politics to make money. you know, we need to actually have this I I think this phenomena of parties breaking up and actually forming more parties or even independent uh uh independent individuals that will end up uh uh what do you call being elected on individual characteristics then we'll end up into formation of coalitions that put the people first these people will then have no choice but to start [31:13] asking the citizen what can I do for you instead of telling the citizen um I'm going to do this accept it because this is for Malay unity this is for uh championing of uh you know the primacy of my religion okay I think we need to throw all this into the dust bean of history. All right. Uh I think I think we are going through not an evolution. I think we are almost going through the revolution. I am whether I like the current uh people that are making noises of leaving their parties or not is irrelevant. In fact, I don't even know half of them personally because I'm a I keep saying to people I [32:06] I look at business and I look at policies, right? If these people put in their business uh right and put in their policies right, I'll vote for them. I want to see what is their um what do you call that? Their manifesto. What they promise and what they're going to deliver and then I look at their character whether they can deliver it or not. I look at their background whether they can deliver it or not. The problem is our politicians start in their 20s, never built anything in their life, don't know about how to actually run anything and then uh like the like like like the snake oil [32:44] salesman in front of uh uh stadium uh in Alo, you know, I I I cannot even hear them talk because they talk nonsense. I want to puke. So let me put it this way guys. We've got an opportunity actually. In fact I almost want to ask DAP get out now. Why are you so got no balls? You got no principle. You need you need six to seven months to assess. You already how long have they been in government? [33:20] Since 2022. Oh before that also. Hey, what what are your boss made of? You got no brains. Uhhuh. You cannot assess it. You cannot have a referendum one year ago. [33:38] Okay. If I may, I sorry, I'm I'm I'm I'm renting already. I'm giving it back to uh if I may, my friend. So, so uh the the changing political landscape, the inability of political parties to win decisive uh outcomes to win decisively at the polls, the inability of any single party to win a simple majority in parliament the last eight years is causing all these issues now. And I think this situation is going to prolong because this is 2026. Now they're saying that the elections, the next elections could be held as early as November this year. [34:23] In any case, it must be held uh next year. So that's next year is you know what, a year less than a year away, you know. So they don't have time. They just don't have time. And uh there's no way all the issues that are outstanding in the country which have not been resolved the last what 50 years. [34:39] Yeah. Is still not going to be resolved. You think you're going to resolve them in the next 12 months? No. And some of these issues are getting worse now and they're coming out of nowhere to me. You know, the issue of those temples is is totally unnecessary. [34:52] I don't know why they make such a fuss about it. You know, there are other ways of handling it. I mean, okay, if it is a issue, you know, there are ways of handling it. Why make it's not an issue. They made an issue out of it. And then each time you create this kind of useless issues, you lose votes. [35:08] I love it. Let them lose votes. But these guys are really they're not very clever. You know that what do you mean they're not very clever? They're not clever. Period. They Why do you create issues that will cost you votes? I mean issues that are not there. [35:21] You know what say nobody cares. It's good. It's good because why? Let them lose votes because at the end of the day you know what I realize something about the business side of the our economy. Do you realize that any improvement in our economy today has got nothing to do with the government for the last three decades at least? [35:41] Okay. Okay. Okay. Let me So the government can come and go. Our private sector will keep on moving. It's independent of the government. Y so the point the point I'm saying is that okay uh let me so don't worry about the economy guys. [35:54] Let me rephrase a bit. The temple issue is not that it does it is not that it has uh what do you call this? uh well it involves private property or government land of course it is an issue but what I'm saying is there's no need to make a big fuss on a national level about it and and as you said it cost them votes they don't they don't seem to understand thish [36:14] so uh over the last 50 years they have not really solved many things so now you have what 12 months or a year left for the next elections are they you're not going to solve all these issues so uh they in quite deep I don't think they're going I don't think they're going to do well at all in the next election. But uh the other the other group of people who are impacted because of the legacy issues because of the heritage the baggage that we have of having one government in power for so long you know the Barisa national for 63 years is the civil service. You know [36:51] when the same government is in place for so long undoubtedly without a doubt uh those who are promoted in the civil service of course they are they must have the right smell. Is that what we said last time? [37:05] The it must smell right. Smell right. The fish got to smell right. So there must be a light. The shadow must be right as well. Things like that. And the civil service you know over the years decades of course uh they the senior civil servants and stuff they are promoted based on their user friend readiness for the government of the day you know which the barista national government at that time for 63 years but that situation has changed now we we've had four prime ministers or five prime ministers in the last how many years last few years so the civil service those and every time this a new [37:43] government comes Now they go through the files or through the records or whatever and they look at all the senior civil servants who were kind of user friendly to the previous government. They will usually get you know um you know well they put away or sent away or whatever. Uh [38:00] we don't have a Siberia to send away. So especially there's a cold storage somewhere. Especially the the senior civil servants who retire. M see in the past in the past in our country you you have senior civil servants who are wellknown who are famous you know uh while they were in the service and then they retire and then once they retired they usually get appointed to some you know eminent position in uh government agencies and in the private sector and I feel many of them deserved it at that time they were really you know uh people of to me of caliber Uh do you remember tun is Ali? [38:41] Well I do but you know what I also those generation were of the generation of uh uh postc colonial we call it you know our our generation and slightly earlier. [38:55] Yes you know okay like Tunis Ali was one he was central the governor of Bangara a man of uh impeccable character. So he was uh after he retired uh from the from as governor of Bangara I think he was appointed chairman of PNB [39:13] and there was another man called Tuna Ahmed Sarji he was also the KSN chief secretary of government and he also took over PNB and we had uh the policeman Tunhan Omar he he served as well and then after he retired he joined a public list company where he had quite a long illustrious career. So those were the the the people in the old days after 2018 uh that has changed uh significantly. People who were recognized as having been too close to previous leadership, previous politicians [39:51] uh they were punished or they were sidelined by the succeeding uh governments. uh that I have personally I'm I know of another governor of the our bank naggara uh who lost his job after uh at some point in the late 1990s early 2000s and uh [40:16] who is that a former governor of Bangara one of the former governors and uh he uh well he was uh well he was shunted aside he didn't get any appointments in the private sector. [40:30] Uhhuh. And then uh I know of um editors of mainstream media especially Malay mainstream media who basically lost their jobs you know and some of them have passed away and they were you know they suffered various um difficulties in the last years of their life things like that and uh there's another guy you know it's a tansri uh also uh recognized or or associated with the previous uh previous administration uh who now I hear runs a plant nursery selling plants you know so many of them their fortunes have not uh um turned out as well in the in their postretirement era again [41:16] this is all because of the change in the political leadership right uh in the country because politics now is very hazardous there's no guarantee that any one single party will remain in power or can win in the next elections, you know. So just like those who are aspiring to be politicians in the future, the civil servants especially senior civil servants also have to be uh careful on how they interact and carry themselves with the government of the day because uh as long as you do your job professionally and you know you obey all the rules and uh uh do things right [42:00] then you do not have anything to worry about uh especially since the government can change at any time or the government can change at the next elections you know. So uh it is less hazardous for the senior civil servants if they uh stick to being professional uh civil servants if they choose to be friendly or overly friendly towards any one person meaning the politicians. uh there could be repercussions on them when the government changes which is uh um not an unlikely thing to happen now in our country. So that's the other group group of people who can face hazards other than [42:47] politicians and the civil servants. If you do your job right, you're okay. But if you, you know, lose track or lose focus for other benefits or for other other reasons, you could uh end up having to answer for your actions when the government changes. So this is a situation now in our country. And uh until we become like Holland or Japan uh and other countries which are more transparent and have a very open system and where the integrity of the system is you know high uh until then uh they have to be careful. The civil service has to be careful and uh just [43:32] focus on doing their job professionally so that they will not have uh too many questions to answer to another government in the future. I I do think that what we are seeing is actually interestingly I never thought about this until you you lay it out. Um but I really do think that this is a this is a change um a moment of um a moment of metamorphosis of our uh governance and administrative system where because the people no longer trust the their elected elected representatives in government that they're willing to take chances and even the elected representative in [44:17] government are finding that they cannot work with each other on certain ideological or even practice that they are breaking up. So it is giving an opportunity for the people to start electing from a different standpoint which is give me your manifesto. I'm going to check I'm going to look at your characteristics and I'm going to vote based on that instead of just giving blank check to the party system. Right? Because the parties are disintegrating. That is what is happening already in but the only thing is that uh the second part the people do not vote for them [44:57] anymore because they cannot see that manifesto they don't understand what these people are doing what is your what is for me but the the political parties like the famous quote by Dr. to Mahade at one time a manifesto is just a manifesto you know [45:12] they're not serious so the failure of the political parties in the countries they are just not going down to the ground and asking people what can I do for you they're refusing to do that [45:24] instead they're talking down to the people and telling them this is what I'm going to do for you and more often than not what they are saying they will do for us is what is good for them first yeah and on top of that when they get into power because money is being siphoned out somewhere else. So there's less money in the government coffers. Then what they're doing is they're doing they're doing additional taxation on the people, [45:50] burdening the people, additional collection on the people. So everything becomes burdened. So for at the at the end of the day my message to our audience is it doesn't matter anymore who you elect and who become government they will work it out because your daily life does not improve. Okay until the time they you start getting people who are actually there to help you to actually do that to do service for you [46:21] regardless they will suck your blood. They will suck your blood. I was listening to this guy a podcaster formerly formerly member of parliament minister and all that. So the interviewer was asking him what would he do if we he became the prime minister [46:37] right and he said he he would widen the tax base. Exactly the thing that that makes you uh really upset you know that's what he said he would widen the tax base so that we can collect more taxes blah blah blah. is all about squeezing the people more for the benefit of the government. [46:56] And then what they do is they start to play this uh this class game. What we we will tax the richer people first. They don't realize the rich people have an option to actually not get taxed because they can move out. [47:12] Well, they're talking about the other rich people, not their rich people. Not their rich people. You see it just as you were mentioning uh about the corruption in third world countries this is not I mean [47:25] this is not unique to Malaysia yeah there's not I mean there's no uh well firm like research or written in stone kind of a figure but easily 25% of uh budget in third world countries is lost in leakage abuse corruption name it uh wrong planning even if there's no corruption they build a bridge where there's no river these things have happened things like that you know so there's wastage you lose about 20 25% it's more than that [47:55] and I feel our country is uh we're not very much different so I feel that if you wipe out corruption we improve efficiency transparency if we become like the Scandinavian countries where local government expenditure is hosted permanently on a website the public can go it anytime time and scrutinize every contract awarded by local governments. You know, they can scrutinize it. What was the pricing? What was the costing? [48:23] What was the margins made? If you if you achieve that level of transparency, you know, I believe we can save easily 20% of our budget. So instead of instead of let's say this 2026 budget 420 billion 10 42 to 80, you could save about 80 billion, you know. So I don't think you need to raise taxes at all. I don't I'm I'm with you on this 100%. You don't need to raise taxes. [48:47] I can cut taxes and make this country better. Yes. You just you just Okay. First of all, you you stop the leakages, stop the corruption. You will save easily about 20%. You say more than that. The other thing is do not build silly useless white elephants. You know why? Why waste money doing silly projects? Huh? Y [49:09] I can I can mention some silly projects but they will involve the 3 hours thing so I won't mention but there's a lot of money wasted in such projects you know uh where there is no direct return into the economy of the country the money is made just once when whoever gets a project they make money by building the project because it's a government project so they they make they get they siphon money as you say taxpayers money after the project is built the returns of the project into the economy it just disappears. You can go to PA you know there's a place called Tas Banding in [49:46] the north near Greek you know where the north house highway is they've built this huge commercial center you know by the lake I think it cost hundreds of millions of ringit but what are the returns who built it some rich guy somebody must have got the contract [50:01] you can find projects like that who funded it it's well this is taxpayer funded one of our taxpayer funded one of the big GLC's you see taxpayer funded so there are projects like this you know which do not generate return into the economy [50:15] it's effectively indirect corruption it's it's wastage of public funds you know so we have projects like this so back to the point that you were trying to make how much can we save uh in our budget you know if we if we if we have if we get rid of corruption the leakages and we don't waste the money doing useless projects now white elephant projects [50:36] okay I still go with figure 20 25% you say maybe more we will save that amount of money from the budget So we will not need to to raise taxes. We not to talk about widening the tax base. I hate when politicians says the word [50:52] I want to make more tax. So this is a guy the guy in the podcast he's he's lost the elections kicked out of his party. I don't know what everything else uh he's saying that if he becomes prime minister that's what he will do. He will increase the tax base. He will burden us. So you see this is the the the mindset their one track mind is [51:12] it's about what you know it's about take money from the people and then spend the money anyway the way I know how to spend within their system their political system political patroniz system that's it that's what they're thinking about that's all so these are the people and by saying this and doing this they honestly think they're going to win big in the next elections [51:32] I think they're totally cut off uh from uh reality they just don't know what's going I I I I I want to say this to our audience. You know, I ask you very simple question. Do you trust these politicians that are in all the seats today to spend your tax money that you pay every month in the right way or not? Ask that question. Does any single one of them you trust? So if you don't trust, why do you give them money to spend? I don't give my children money if I don't trust them to spend their money. These people are our children, you know. They are not our parents. They are stupider [52:18] than us. Okay? We cover our we spend our money better than how they spend. So uh if I may wrap up my points. So you see uh the the uh bottom line is this has been going on for the last decades, [52:38] six decades decades, you know. Yeah. And now there is 12 months or less or slightly more for the next election. Do we honestly think they're going to change anything in the next 12 months? No, it's not going to change. Meaning meaning do you think any one of these people is going to win big in the next election? No. It's going to be another hung parliament or they're going to get kicked out or things like that. You know, nothing is going to change for them. The only thing they have left is they can form this unwieldy and weird coalitions to stay in power. Uh but they [53:10] don't realize that they can win big in the elections. they can make a major what do you call this paradigm shift in the in the in the voting uh landscape that means get back power win more than a simple majority if you just go down to the people and ask them what can I do for you [53:30] but I don't think at this stage if you ask me say I don't think they will all right and the reason why I don't think they will is because the hurt has not really hit them okay you know I I almost think now the the more you talk the more I start thinking right I'm almost expecting I wish it becomes like the UK or the Netherlands or even Italy in which case uh every one year we change government because the government collapse all right imagineh imagine every year you're not happy people have to leave the coalition okay and the government collapse and election [54:12] is required you start changing people again. Well, it happened here after Dr. Mahade became PM 2.0. He lasted for 22 months and then there was a change in the coalition replaced by Tansri Mahudin. He lasted [54:27] about more than a year, 17 months or something but there was no election. Yes. But the government fell because the coalition changed. They pulled the support. But what we want to see is the people who gets end up having to form a coalition is through another election. [54:44] Yeah. Well, they've lost. Yeah. Bottom line is they have lost the support of the people. So we need the next stage. We need the next stage. They certainly don't have the support of their their coalition partners. I'm referring to the previous governments. Dr. Mahade 2.0, Tani Mahidin and the Isma Sabri government. They didn't last. what you said about happening in Italy, it happened three times here and uh it can happen again. [55:07] Let it happen. It can happen again. Yeah. Exactly what happened to Dr. Mahadei, exactly what happened to Tanri Mahidin, exactly what happened to Isal Sabri, Dr. Ismile Sabri, it can happen again. I think it is because the way things are going now, you know, at the beginning of the of this podcast, you mentioned that DAP is having issues. Basu has broken up, you know. So none of them are going into the next election on firm footing and with the with that statement by the DAP YB for Kota Malaka just a couple days ago in parliament things are not getting better for them you know they're [55:42] just beginning to crack up so they're going into the next election which is due in like a year or about there and they still cracking up they're not going to they're not going to be able to form firm solid governments and the scenario that you are painting which has already happened under Dr. Mahadeim Mah and is Sabri can happen again. [56:02] That's the reality now. But these guys as you say these politicians today, they don't seem to care. No, this is the difference. This is why the paradigm need to shift from a rearranging of the coalition by the already elected MP to a disintegration of government and then a need for another general election to elect new people. keep electing new people and you keep kicking out. It's basically [56:32] keep changing the dirty diapers. Keep changing the dirty diapers. The way every time the wave come into the ocean, we get rid of all the deadwood and bring in another tsunami. I I want to close this podcast in one thing just to let people understand this. All right. Okay. We always speak about Singapore being actually their their their currency used to be smaller than ours. Today the our per capita GDP in US dollar today is about 14,000 USD. Okay. Per capita. All right. Per per capita perom. Now Singapore is close to I think between 80 to 90,000. Okay. Put Singapore aside. [57:25] You say it's a small city state. Okay. South Korea is at 37 38,000 USD per capita. All right. They were when we achieved our independence, they were still at war with North Korea. All right. Their people were still living um uh what do you call in agriculture. Japan. Japan today is about 40,000. That is why I can tell 40 45,000 Japan. All right? And the reason is very simple. You corrupt, I send you to jail. You corrupt, I bring down the government, I bring new people. So at the end of the day, this is the private sector. Only thing we need is the civil service to keep doing their job. Okay. [58:26] The private sector will keep going. We will build data centers. We will we will keep on producing palm oil. We will keep manufacturing uh integrated circuits [58:38] electronics electronics and whatnot. Okay. We will keep on bringing funds. It's not the government that is bringing funds. It is the private sector that is bringing funds. The only thing we need to do is get rid of people who are not doing service to our interest as citizens to come to us and say back us. With all that, I want to close this podcast. Say it. All right. [59:24] Okay. Let the let let the what do you call? Let the uh scal Thank you so much. See you again. Thank you.